Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 292-305 Available online at http://ejournal.
id/index.
php/medianers DOI: 10.
14710/nmjn.
The Relationship between Job Stress and Job Satisfaction among Saudi Nurses: A Cross-Sectional Study Omar Ghazi Baker1.
Bandar Dhafer Alshehri2 College of Nursing.
King Saud University.
Riyadh.
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Nursing Administration Department.
King Saud Medical City.
Riyadh.
Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Corresponding Author: Omar Ghazi Baker .
baker70@gmail.
obaker@ksu.
Received: 8 September 2020
Revised: 15 December 2020
Accepted: 19 December 2020
ABSTRACT
Background: The productivity of nurses and patient healthcare is highly influenced by nursesAo stress-related factors and job satisfaction.
Nursing is the least preferred career opportunities for Saudi residents as compared to other options.
NursesAo perceptions of intention to quit contributes to their shortage in Saudi health care institutions.
Purpose: The study aimed to examine the relationship between work-related stress and job satisfaction among Saudi nurses working at a public hospital.
Methods: The research used a cross-sectional design that collected data from samples of 297 nurses working at a specified public hospital and aged over than 20 years old.
Convenient sampling was employed to recruit the samples.
Data were collected using the Expanded Nursing Stress Scale (ENSS) and Job Satisfaction Scale (JSS).
The Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) version 20.
0 was applied, and PearsonAos correlation test was to identify the relationship between variables.
Results: The results indicated that the nurses at the hospital where the study took place experienced low levels of stress with a mean value of 2.
Besides, the nature of work indicated maximum job satisfaction with a mean value of 15.
666, whereas minimum job satisfaction levels .
, were related to benefits provided to nurses.
A positive correlation was found between the level of stress and satisfaction with a p-value of 0.
Conclusion: The stress factors were highly correlated with job satisfaction.
The identification of stress factors is important as it may create a negative impact on patientsAo care and their well-being.
It is suggested that changes in managerial affairs and policies are essential for implementing beneficial strategies that may assist in resolving the issue.
Keywords: Nurses.
patient care.
Saudi Arabia.
work-related stress How to Cite: Baker.
, & Alshehri.
Relationship between job stress and job satisfaction among Saudi nurses: A cross-sectional study.
Nurse Media Journal of Nursing.
, 292-305.
doi:10.
14710/nmjn.
Permalink/DOI: https://doi.
org/10.
14710/nmjn.
BACKGROUND
Nurses are considered integral for ensuring the nationAos adequate health, while studies have recognized it as the most stressful profession (Chien & Yick, 2016.
Muhawish.
Saleem.
Baker.
Elbilgahy & Hashem, 2.
Muhawish et al.
stated that stress Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 293 jeopardizes individual and organizational efficiency.
For instance, it causes an adverse impact on the nurse job satisfaction, well-being, and health at an individual level, and leads to increased turnover and absenteeism at an organizational level.
This eventually causes an adverse impact on healthcare efficiency and quality (Sharma et al.
, 2.
Stress can also transform into a negative phenomenon if it is intense and continuous, leading to physical illnesses and psychological disorders (Gulavani & Shinde, 2.
AbuRuz .
stated that undesirable consequences result due to work-related stress among nurses that decreases their level of job satisfaction.
Chien and YickAos .
study provided an international perspective concerning nurse stress and strain.
The study confirmed it as the most stressful profession across different industries and on a global This is also evident from its prevalence at 55% (Nasr-Esfahani.
Masoumi & Mohamadirizi, 2.
Dagget.
Molla, and Belachew .
, further showed that jobrelated stress affects 9.
2-68% of the total nurse population.
Job satisfaction is among the most significant organizational problem concerning job stress (Hosseinabadi & Etemadinezhad, 2018.
Nehrir.
Ebadi.
Tofighi.
Karimi Zarchi, & Honarvar, 2010.
Shahnazi.
Daniali & Sharifirad, 2.
There is an increase in the level of self-confidence, improved physical, mental and social health, improved communication, and reduction in the level of psychological distress due to job satisfaction (Shahnazi et al.
, 2.
Other factors such as salary, job dimensions, company policies, and personality characteristics also affect the level of job satisfaction among nurses (Emadzadeh.
Khorasani & Nemtizadeh, 2.
Nurses experience a variant level of job stress when they are unable to meet the work requirements that negatively affect their performance, leading to job dissatisfaction.
Previous research reported a positive association between job satisfaction and staff performance (Mohammadi, 2.
Also, similar findings were reported by a study conducted among Saudi nurses working in the critical care unit (Awajeh.
Issa.
Rasheed, & Amirah, 2.
The environment is usually stressful due to different factors where in which nurses work.
Soltanmoradi.
Ansari, and Heidari .
determined the sources of stress among Iranian nurses working in the University of Medical Sciences.
Iran.
Among various reasons, death and dying were the most top-rated situations that were stressful for Iranian nurses.
contrast to this, discrimination among nurses was identified as the least stressful variable.
Another common reason includes treatments related to various uncertainties.
Similarly, the rate of stress in the general operating rooms was significant, with the highest mean scores of conflicts with a physician along with inadequate preparation (Soltanmoradi et , 2.
Chaudhari.
Mazumdar.
Motwani and Ramadas .
conducted a study to further highlight the levels of occupational stress among western nurses.
The results showed that almost half of the overall nurses experienced mild stress.
the other 34% experienced moderate stress.
The remaining 2% of nurses experienced high-level stress.
Besides, the study has identified different reasons that serve as the sources of stress among American The factors include conflicts with families and supervisors, and increasing workload serves as the leading cause of stress.
Similarly, nurses with professional Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 294 experience of almost 6-10 years faced maximum stress.
Jackson .
pinpointed the sources of satisfaction among nurses.
the factors, include maximum level of age .
ldest or younges.
, nurses with masterAos degree, and females belonging to two or more races.
Garcya-Izquierdo.
Meseguer de Pedro.
Ryos-Risquez and Synchez .
showed that stress emerges due to interpersonal conflicts, inadequate social support, and patientinduced violence, which leads to burnout development .
hronic stres.
To subside its impact, nursing attitude and their relationship with their peers, colleagues, and supervisor are found to reduce their stress levels.
The offering of economic benefits, including a better salary, can lead to a reduced stress level and induces job satisfaction.
This highlights the need for a study that analyses the correlation between job stress and job satisfaction level to help overcome the adverse outcome on nurses, facilitating the provision of better care quality.
Similar to other countries, the Saudi healthcare sector is also found to suffer from increased stress leading to nurse shortage.
Almajwal .
noted a shortage of nurses in Saudi Arabia, which present only 25% of the overall workforce.
In addition.
Saudi Arabia experiences a shortage of nursing staff with one nurse for 296 patients, unlike the developed countries having one nurse for 135 patients (Ministry of Health [MOH], 2.
Besides, the ratio of population and nurses is also projected to be below the developed countries (World Health Organization, 2.
, emphasizing a further analysis of nursesAo job satisfaction and stress level.
Further, studies also indicate that workload increases due to nurse shortages, leading to psychological distress (Li et al.
, 2.
, which is likely to affect the care delivery to patients.
Based on each nurseAos individual differences, there is an increased chance of developing work-related stress that leads to differences in job For instance, almost 3,950 nurses in King Saud Medical City received 06225 million patients within one year.
Thereby, continuous complaints are received by nurses regarding work-related stress.
A previous study showed that health care systems and patient care is negatively affected as a result of stress, depression, job satisfaction, and psychological distress (Salam, 2.
Improved quality of care and a reduction in medical errors are possible when work-related stress is reduced and job satisfaction is increased among the nurses.
This also helps contribute to the Saudization policy of the country (Alboliteeh.
Magarey & Wiechula, 2.
Previous studies have indicated a more significant influence of stress on job satisfaction of nurses.
The complexity of critically ill patientsAo circumstances and workload in the hospital put forth nurses under further stressors.
A research study is needed to reduce the adverse outcomes on nurses, correlating the role of job stressors on the satisfaction rates of nurses.
In this research, the researchers have hypothesized a correlation between the two factors: job satisfaction and job-related stressors among nurses.
Therefore, there is a need to investigate the relationship between work-related stress and job satisfaction to direct the administrators towards reducing stress and increasing job satisfaction among nurses in Saudi Arabia.
PURPOSE
The present study aimed to examine the relationship between work-related stress and job satisfaction among Saudi nursing staff.
Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 295
METHODS
Research design and participants The study adopted a cross-sectional design to investigate the relationship between workrelated stress and job satisfaction among Saudi nurses.
The emergency department, intensive care unit (ICU), surgical ward, neuroscience ward, dialysis ward, and pediatric ward in a public hospital in Riyadh.
Saudi Arabia, were approached for collecting data from nurses.
These units were incorporated, given the lack of studies concerning the cumulative effect.
The samples comprised 297 nurses that were recruited using a convenient sampling method, which provided a minute opportunity to control for biases.
The sample size was computed using the sample size formula, where the population was 1,000.
The error of margin was kept at 5% and the confidence interval at 95%.
The sample size for it should be at least 278.
The targeted sample size was justified using the Raosoft sampling size The nurses who were above 20 years old, registered nurses, and working at the specified hospital fulfilled the inclusion criteria.
No confounding factors were used to confine the sample size.
Among them, those who gave consent to participate in the study were recruited.
The nurses lacking any of these qualities were excluded from this Figure .
depicts the overall selection procedure.
Research instrument and data collection The data in this study were collected using the Expanded Nursing Stress Scale (ENSS) and Job Satisfaction Scale (JSS) .
riginal version.
between July 2017 to December 2017.
Job-related stressors among nurses were measured using the ENSS, an expanded and updated revision of the classic Nursing Stress Scale (NSS) developed by Gray-Toft and Anderson .
The ENSS is a validated and widely used scale to assess work associated stress among nurses (MilutinovicA.
GolubovicA.
BrkicA & ProkesU, 2.
connection with the changing times of the domestic work environment in nursing, the ENSS scale is also the updated version of NSS to accommodate the effect of stressful conditions such as the dying and death of patients, unfair demands of patients and their families, various violence, conflict with peers, conflict with physicians, working with opposite gender nurses, or discrimination are the recent problems faced by the nurses (French.
Lenton.
Walters, & Eyles, 2.
Meanwhile, the JSS is also a validated tool to assess job satisfaction level in hospital jobs and on nursing staff (Kvist et al.
, 2.
The ENSS targets the prevalence of stress among the nursing staff by measuring the frequency and major sources of stress in patient care situations similar to that of NSS.
However.
NSS is updated to ENSS to accommodate the change in stress factors with respect to the changing nursing environment.
The degree to which people like their jobs was assessed through JSS (Spector, 1.
This scale provides an overall job satisfaction score after the assessment of nine facets that include: pay, promotion, supervision, fringe benefits, contingent rewards, operating conditions, coworkers, nature of work, and The questions were responded on a 6-point scale for each item .
=much disagreement, 2=disagree moderately, 3=disagree slightly, 4=agree slightly, 5=agree moderately, and 6=agree very muc.
The values for stress level were differentiated in three sections: continuum, descriptive meanings .
99 = does not apply, to 4.
0 and above = above extrem.
, and overall meaning interpretation .
99 = no stress, to 4.
Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 296 and above = very high level of stres.
In addition, satisfaction was measured on a threeitem scale .
00 = dissatisfied to 16.
00 = satisfie.
In the present study.
CronbachAos coefficient alpha was calculated for determining the reliability of the subscales of ENSS (MilutinovicA et al.
, 2.
and NSS (Gray-Toft & Anderson, 1.
The alpha scores of the questions ranged between 0.
70 to 0.
85, showing good reliability.
The validity of the questionnaire was calculated with proper designing, piloting, and addressing the reference groupAos feedback.
The questionnaires were administered to the nurses with the presence of a researcher for clarifying unclear questions.
Similar instructions were provided to all recruited nurses.
Enough time was provided to the nurses for filling the questionnaires and this entire procedure was completed in four weeks.
Figure 1.
ParticipantsAo selection Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 297 Data analysis The data collected through the questionnaires were coded and entered on the excel sheet for analysis.
The completeness of the questionnaire was verified after completing the procedure of data collection.
The data from excel was coded and analyzed using Statistical Package Social Science Software (SPSS) version 20.
The characteristics of nurses and the level of stress and satisfaction among them were determined using the descriptive statistics, whereas the relationship between stress and job satisfaction among nurses was investigated using PearsonAos correlation test.
Ethical considerations This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board (IRB) of King Saud University [Ref.
No.
17/0292/IRB, 29 March 2.
Permission to use the ENSS and JSS in this study was also obtained from their original authors.
All the recruited nurses were explained of the studyAos purpose and procedures.
Also, a sign was obtained for an informed consent form explaining their rights in the study.
RESULTS
Demographic characteristics of the respondents The results of this study showed that the majority of the respondents were females, with an overall percentage of 89.
9%, and belonged to the age group between 20-30 years old, with a given percentage of 53.
Furthermore, most of them .
4%) were holding BachelorAos degree and working in the unit with a duration of above 4 years .
5%).
Similarly, 82.
2% of nurses were working in the night shift, while 82.
2% of nurses were on rotation shifts.
Most nurses were employed as registered nurses, between 5 to 10 years, with a given percentage of 40.
Concerning the nursesAo level of salary, most of the nurses were paid between SAR 5,000 to 10,000 .
7%).
Table 1 provides a detailed description of the characteristics of the respondents.
Level of stress and satisfaction among nurses Table 2 provides results related to the level of stress among nurses.
According to the results, the given participantsAo stress level is low, with a mean value of 2.
Regarding the level of satisfaction among nurses, findings proposed that most of the nurses were dissatisfied with the benefits provided to them, with a mean value of 11.
Contrary to this, maximum satisfaction was provided for the nature of work with a mean value of The correlation between the level of stress and satisfaction is provided in Table 3.
Results indicate a positive association between the level of stress and promotion, with a significant p-value of 0.
Moreover, participants with maximum satisfaction level in terms of the level of promotion usually experience maximum stress.
In contrast to this, participants with low satisfaction level towards promotion experience minimum stress.
Therefore, the results indicate that the level of satisfaction among nurses is not entirely related to stress.
Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 298 Table 1.
Demographic characteristics of respondents .
Demographic characteristics Gender Male Female Age 20-30 years 31-40 years 41-50 years >50 years Marital Status Single Married Education Level Diploma Bachelors Masters Duration in the unit <1 year 1-4 years >4 years Shift Day Night Frequency .
Percentage (%) Nature Day Night Rotating Table 2: Level of stress and satisfaction among nurses .
Stress Satisfaction (Subscale.
Pay Promotion Supervision Fringe/Benefits Contingent Operating Conditions Coworkers Nature of Work Communication Satisfaction Min Max Mean Remarks Low stress Ambivalent Ambivalent Ambivalent Dissatisfied Ambivalent Ambivalent Ambivalent Ambivalent Ambivalent Ambivalent Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 299 Table 3: Correlation between levels of stress and satisfaction among nurses .
Components of Satisfaction Stress Pay Promotion Supervision Fringe Benefits Contingent Operation Co-workers Nature of work Communication Satisfaction Level of Stress Point Biserial Correlation PearsonAos Correlation p-value Correlation is significant at the level of 0.
DISCUSSION
The study intended to explore the relationship between stress and job satisfaction among nurses through various variables.
The health care manager, nursing instructors, and hospital policymakers would be able to provide appropriate strategies and programs for promoting job satisfaction by understanding the association between job-related stress and job satisfaction among the nurses.
The level of productivity and efficiency among nurses is likely to increase by promoting job satisfaction, which would improve their performance (Ella.
Asuquo.
Akpan-Idiok, & Ijabula, 2.
Results in this study have indicated that supervision, operating conditions, nature of work, satisfaction and communication are associated with high-level job satisfaction among These results are supported by Loh.
Gan.
Lim.
Loh, and Yong .
, which showed that supervisorAos support provided a positive influence on job satisfaction among Kula and Guler .
also indicated similar findings and concluded that supervisor support is important in providing job satisfaction to nurses (Kula & Guler.
Results of the present study are also endorsed by Saleh.
Saleh, and AbuRuz .
, as the maximum level of job satisfaction among nurses was related to the nature of work with a mean value of 4.
However, the minimum level of job satisfaction was related to the operating conditions with a mean value of 2.
The findings highlight that the work environment and job-related benefits of the health care organization should be redesigned for promoting positive outcomes.
This involves the instigation of a better system that uses transparent practices concerning the reporting and as well as providing support for improved satisfaction level.
The practitioners are suggested to introduce different reimbursement practices that recognized nursesAo high performance and productivity.
This could be based on fewer complaints of the patients or on regularity, as these are the primary factors that affect the care quality.
Improvements should be instigated in terms of individual responsibilities, work delegation, and breaks Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 300 to help eliminate the stress-inducing promoters.
To ensure healthy interaction among the staff and the patient, different strict protocols can be implemented.
Nurses should be provided with counseling sessions as well as practices that enable them to communicate with the patient and the staff, and this should follow a continual screening procedure where nurses are frequently screened for identifying any psychological distress (Villani et al.
, 2.
Also, policies should be implemented by the Ministry of Health and the management of the hospital to address the factors that lead to stress.
Besides, different psychological distressed interventions could be performed to improve the nurse satisfaction level (Heath.
Sommerfield & von UngernAaSternberg, 2.
The curriculum highlighting the stress-inducing factors should also be introduced along with the different interventions that can be applied for reducing it.
Results indicated that the majority of the nurses belonged to the age group between 2030 years, while 40% of the total nurses were employed as registered nurses from 5-10 Salaries for most of the nurses ranged between SAR 5,000-10,000.
The literature suggests that job satisfaction leads to decreased job-related stress.
Kvist et al.
further suggests that this job satisfaction is related to the perceived quality of care provided by their unit.
Holmberg.
Sobis, and Carlstrym .
found a strong correlation between a good salary and job satisfaction.
As in this study, the nurses had a steady salary and were mostly registered for 5-10 years.
the results indicated low levels of stress among the given sample of nurses.
Participants that enjoy maximum promotion usually experience a high level of stress.
This could be due to the effect of promotion on job Razak.
Sarpan, and Ramlan .
posit that promotion to dominant or positions with responsibilities often affects job performance, which could lead to added job-related stress.
Results of the study are in contrast to those proposed by Jawad.
Jeffery and Wanton .
, according to which, the level of stress among nurses increases with the deaths of patients.
In contrast to this, the minimum stress level was related to the emotional needs of patients.
Similarly, results of the present study are in contrast to the results proposed in the study of Galdikiene.
Asikainen.
Baciunas, and Suominen .
They posit inadequate preparation of nurses, conflicts with a physician, problems with supervisor and coworkers, served as the major stress factors among nurses.
Also, most of the nurses, when working as a team, experienced stress due to treatment uncertainties.
Chatzigianni.
Tsounis.
Markopoulos, and Sarafis .
provided conflicting results regarding age and stress among nurses.
According to the findings, nurses aged between 30-34 years experienced maximum stress and vice versa.
The findings contradict the results proposed in the present study since the studyAos maximum population belongs to the age group between 20-30 years.
There was a positive and significant impact on nursesAo perceptions of their promotion on their job stress.
Consequently, the impact of effective promotion in the work environment is examined on the individual, including job satisfaction.
The transmission of information can be obstructed in multicultural personnel such as the ones revealed in the industry because of differences in values, beliefs, religion, attitudes, behaviors, education, and cultural norms of individuals.
Increased job satisfaction, enhanced working conditions.
Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 301 and additional opportunities for professional growth were the reasons cited for returning to nursing profession.
Likewise, nursesAo professional growth is improved by educational opportunities and therefore had a substantial influence on job satisfaction.
Transparent organizational policies are required to increase communication satisfaction and influence nursesAo intention to leave health institution jobs to a greater extent.
Staff should be aware of better communications throughout the institution and be able to play an active role in solving issues that root from the paucity of communication.
In this regard, the support of the systematic enhancements and hospital administration for all staff will be required for assuring communication satisfaction among nurses.
Efficient feedback frameworks can be developed for nursing applications to reduce the communication chaos and conflicts faced by nurses in health care centers.
Administrators can reduce nursesAo intention to quit by facilitating them with a trust-based work environment and giving them a higher quality of work life.
Several factors are highlighted that create a valuable impact on job satisfaction among The identification of stress factors is important as they may create a negative impact on patientsAo care and their well-being (Arnetz.
Sudan.
Goetz.
Counts & Arnetz.
Nurses also reflect a sense of dissatisfaction with their jobs resulting in high turnover rates and absenteeism, which directly impacts the quality of patient care (Arnetz et al.
, 2.
According to the given results, nurses enjoying maximum promotions have a significantly high level of stress.
Maximum job satisfaction was related to the nature of The results of the study are important as they provide an important evaluation regarding the stress factors among nurses.
This provides a responsibility to nursesAo managers to make important measures that may reduce the level of stress among nurses while providing maximum job satisfaction.
The results provided in the study exposed several different factors that may directly impact the level of job satisfaction among Change in policies and managerial affairs are important to implement useful strategies that may help to resolve the issue.
Despite the abundant information, the research involves certain limitations in the form of time and financial resources.
The use of a cross-sectional study design limits the study results as the cause of the stress cannot be determined.
It was also conducted on a single institute, which limits its results generalization to a greater population.
The study is further limited due to the small sample size, as some of the nurses refused to participate due to work management or unavailability.
This provides an opportunity for future researchers to conduct the study by involving a large sample in other Saudi Arabia Findings provided in the study are important and can be implied in other Saudi Arabia hospitals to a certain extent.
Further studies help policymakers make important measures regarding stress factors among nurses working in the specified hospital where the study took place.
Future studies can include the qualitative research design for comprehensively evaluating the different stress-inducing factors.
Also, different interventions can be introduced and evaluated concerning its impact on the nurse stress level as well as satisfaction.
This study has recommended that the shortage of nurses in Saudi Arabia can be handled by appropriate nursing management by making enhancements in communication Copyright A 2020.
NMJN, p-ISSN 2087-7811, e-ISSN 2406-8799 Nurse Media Journal of Nursing, 10.
, 2020, 302 satisfaction and work environment, as this would reduce nursesAo intention to quit.
Thereby, the nursing management bodies should emphasize promoting a professional practice environment to protect job satisfaction among nurses.
Consequently, healthcare centers can accomplish the objective of providing quality care to the patients.
The goal of patientsAo enhancement is directly proportional to the better professional work environment in the job satisfaction and well-being among nurses.
CONCLUSION
This cross-sectional study showed the relationship between work-related stress and job satisfaction among Saudi nurses involved in the study.
Using the ENSS and JSS, the results depicted that the promotion of the nursesAo help mitigates the stress level among The healthcare management at the hospital needs to induce different policies and practices that help overcome the professional outbreak among the Saudi nurses and improve their satisfaction level.
These practices are likely to help improve patientsAo care and their well-being.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The researchers are very thankful to all the associated personnel in any reference that contributed to/for this research.
FUNDING
This research is not funded by any resources.
COMPETING INTEREST:
The author declares no competing interest.
REFERENCES