Agroindustrial Journal 12 .
2025, 94-112 Community-Based Management on Isolated Islands for Socio-economic Development Ai A systematic review Fitriana Dina Rizkina1,2*.
Naruhito Takenouchi1.
Hiroki Kasamatsu1 The United Graduate School of Agricultural Sciences.
Ehime University, 3-5-7 Tarumi.
Matsuyama.
Ehime, 790-8566 Japan Department of Agricultural Industrial Technology.
Faculty of Agriculture.
Universitas Muhammadiyah Jember.
Jl.
Karimata No.
Jember.
East Java, 68121 Indonesia Email: fitrianadina@unmuhjember.
Received: June-30-2025.
Accepted: December-16-2025.
Published: December-30-2025 Abstract This review paper offers a thorough understanding of the literature on research in isolated island communities from the past 10 years.
It uses the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) First, the study identified 190 research papers from reputable international publishers, then selected 23 for the final stage.
The review highlights the policy implications of community-based management in agriculture .
, agroindustry, fisheries, and social science.
The review reveals popular research topics discussed in recent studies and provides insight into the methods or approaches used.
Our review's results show that specific methods are relevant and are still widely used by 39% of studies.
Additionally, future research is expected to explore topics that have not been widely studied, particularly agroindustry.
The percentage of agroindustry studies in the CBM review results on isolated islands reflects this situation, representing only 9% of the total, while fisheries represent 52%, social science 22%, and agriculture 17%.
Keywords: community-based management.
isolated islands.
INTRODUCTION
Poverty is a challenge to the development of isolated community welfare in developing Communities on isolated islands have available resources .
atural and socia.
, but studies show that the availability of an islandAos natural resource potential has not been able to increase the welfare of the people who are still trapped in poverty (Miranti, 2019.
Panggarti et al.
, 2022.
Sugiyarto et al.
, 2.
This situation negatively affects communities in terms of low productivity and community income, resulting in difficulties in accessing health and education services, food insecurity and malnutrition, limited infrastructure, and vulnerability to resource exploitation.
Community-based management contributes to reducing poverty, where communities that have strong collective action capabilities can better plan and implement projects.
For instance, in Southeast Asia (Beard, 2019.
Yasmi et al.
, 2.
, communities with robust collective action were more successful in planning independently, such as in Indonesia (Beard and Dasgupta, 2006.
Fahmi et al.
, 2.
and Thailand (Beard and Phakphian, 2012.
Kitipadung and Jaiborisudhi, 2.
There is still not much discussion about the relationship between socio-economic structural conditions and potential in isolated communities.
This paper discusses community-based management for the socio-economic structure of isolated islands in agriculture .
, agroindustry, fisheries, and social science.
Ibnusina et al.
stated that local wisdom has the potential to transform innovation in coastal communities on isolated islands, such as the Solomon Islands, bringing innovation management to marine products (Trihatmoko et al.
, 2.
, through empowering local workers to improve welfare (Abernethy et al.
, 2014.
Batalofo et al.
, 2023.
Eriksson et al.
, 2020.
Mauli et al.
, 2023.
Rizkina et al.
, 2025.
Schwarz et al.
, 2.
Therefore, for a comprehensive study of the development of economies, showing the socioeconomic structure of an isolated community, supported by a literature review from Asian countries or developing countries, is necessary.
The integration of findings and research gaps are analysed for the Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 (No.
, 2025, 94-112, doi: 10.
22146/aij.
Copyright ye 2025 to The Author.
This article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 4.
0 International License.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
basic sources of this review paper (Castro et al.
, 2024.
Milupi et al.
, 2017.
Pomeroy and Carlos, 1.
Both Milupi et al.
and Pomeroy and Carlos .
emphasized the critical role of empowering local communities on isolated islands.
The papers also suggested fostering co-management structures involving local governments.
NGOs, and community organisations to ensure sustainable socio-economic growth (Milupi et al.
, 2017.
Pomeroy and Carlos, 1.
In addition.
Castro et al.
elaborated on digital community management by integrating online platforms with agricultural market linkages, knowledge exchange, and community participation (Karyawati et al.
, 2.
Insight from Pomeroy and Carlos .
is important for resource-based activities .
, reforestation and alternative livelihood.
, and Milupi et al.
emphasised monitoring aligned with agricultural needs for resource resilience on isolated islands.
Research gaps can be supported from the literature review: digital connectivity (Castro et al.
, 2.
, conflict resolution (Milupi et al.
, 2017.
Pomeroy and Carlos, 1.
, and equity and inclusivity (Milupi et al.
, 2.
This review should help answer potential research questions of the isolated community in socioeconomic conditions while highlighting a deeper understanding of the problem that is useful as a basis for future research.
Understanding the socio-economic structural conditions clearly is useful as a first step in answering community problems on isolated islands (Sodjinou, 2.
In addition, this study strengthens how research on small island developing states aligns with sustainable development goals (SDG.
Its findings stressed the importance of cooperation and collaborative efforts.
Therefore, this review paper is aligned with the SDG framework to give the paper a stronger direction.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
This systematic review was performed using Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis (PRISMA), an evidence-based reporting method comprising a minimum set of elements for meta-analysis and reorganization.
PRISMA has been used in several studies, such as Rocha et al.
This method has four processes: .
defining the research question (RQ), .
determining the source of articles, .
conducting a search for articles related to the RQ, and .
analyzing the search outcomes.
In this review, we highlighted significant research formulations and sought applicable The research questions for this review are shown in Table 1, based on the key direction shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1.
The key directions in the review papers RQ1
RQ2
Table 1.
Research questions and justification.
Research questions (RQ) Justification What are the trends and main highlights This research question aims to investigate and that summarize the state-of-the-art analyze recent trends in CBM methods to community-based management (CBM) evaluate its current state, and then assess how methods in the academic literature? well they are being adopted with recent CBM trends (Kaponda and Chiwaridzo, 2.
and food security (Sari and Masitah, 2.
What about data collection? How is it Our main observations are summarized by the collected and how is it evaluated? question about the surveyed methods.
The answer will be mainly divided into two sections:
first, the data-related observations are listed, and next, we elaborate on our observations and highlight the surveyed methods.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
RQ3
Research questions (RQ) Is there a gap between academic research and the practices in the CBM
RQ4
What are the possible future directions for CBM development on isolated Justification We not only analyze recent academic works but also pioneering social and commercial CBM projects in an attempt to assess the gap between academic research and society in the domain of communities on isolated islands.
In this research question, we aim to compile a list of the insufficiently addressed research areas and techniques.
In addition, we aim to list possible novel research directions in the targeted In this review paper, we used relevant literature that came from literature that was published between 1 January 2014 and 10 January 2025.
The journals and conference proceedings were obtained from Elsevier.
Science Direct.
IOP Science.
MDPI.
Ie Xplore.
Google Scholar.
Wiley.
Taylor & Francis.
Sage Publishing, and Emerald.
A further selection step was applying criteria shown in Table 2.
flowchart of the selection process is shown in Figure 4.
Table 2.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria Inclusion Criteria Exclusion Criteria Elsevier.
Science Direct.
IOP Science.
MDPI.
Ie Books, reviews, short articles, and journal Xplore.
Google Scholar.
Wiley.
Taylor & Francis, editorial statements.
Sage Publishing, and Emerald Published between 1 January 2014 and 10 January Available in full-text Papers written in English Articles must include a certain combination of words, i.
, .
ommunity-based managemen.
solated islands/rural .
griculture/agroindustry/fisheries/forestr.
ocial economic structur.
Published outside 1 January 2014 to 10 January 2025 Unavailable in full-text Papers not written in English Articles did not include a certain combination .
ommunity-based managemen.
solated islands/rural are.
griculture/agroindustry/fisheries/forestr.
ocial economic structur.
After applying the criteria, 23 articles were included in the review, as shown in Table 3.
Figure 2.
Figure 3, and Figure 4 (Kuncoro et al.
, 2.
Figure 2.
Descriptive statistical analysis based on .
publication year of the literature studies, and .
subject keywords of the literature studies Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
Figure 3.
Bibliometric network of literature reviews : .
based on the related topic and .
based on the year of publication No.
Table 3.
Selected articles, date of publication, and number of citations Author Publication Year Citation Number Publisher Country Wilson et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Kruse et al.
Elsevier Netherlands UrsiN et al.
Emerald Group United Kingdom Publishing Ltd.
Reynolds et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Sok and Yu Elsevier/KeAi China Communications Co.
Murhaini and Elsevier Netherlands Achmadi Islam.
, et 2021 Emerald Group United Kingdom Publishing Ltd.
Delgado et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Casola et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Basel et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Wahyono and IOP Publishing Ltd.
United Kingdom Illiyani Paulangan et IOP Publishing Ltd.
United Kingdom Prieto-Carolino Elsevier United Kingdom et al.
Nwankwo et al.
SAGE Publications United States Inc.
Molina Emerald Group United Kingdom Publishing Ltd.
Teniwut et al.
IOP Publishing Ltd.
United Kingdom Schwarz et al.
South Pacific Malaysia Commission Romero Elsevier United Kingdom Manrique de Lara and Corral Prodhan et al.
IOS Press BV Netherlands Corral and Elsevier United Kingdom Manrique de Lara Remling and Emerald Group United Kingdom Veitayaki Publishing Ltd.
Patankar et al.
Elsevier United Kingdom Suh SAGE Publications United Kingdom Inc.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
Figure 4.
Flowchart of the included studies describing community-based management on isolated RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Studies of community-based management (CBM) continue to develop alongside the increasingly crucial problems of agriculture .
, fisheries, agroindustry, and social economics in community life, especially in rural areas and on isolated islands.
Additionally, studying management solutions is necessary to maximize the potential and benefits of bioresource business management.
Over the past few years.
CBM studies have advanced significantly through numerous case studies.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
including those on sustainable agriculture (Kaponda and Chiwaridzo, 2.
and food security (Sari and Masitah, 2.
In this publication review on community-based management, we examined 23 papers from 190 papers.
Several researchers highlight the sustainability of supporting the lives of people in remote island communities (Wu et al.
, 2.
Based on the literature study, as shown in Figure 5, a CBM case study outline has been compiled, which is classified based on trends and main highlights, as shown in Table 4.
Figure 5.
Research block diagram of the literature reviews No.
Table 4.
Outline of CBM case studies, trends, and main highlights Reference CBM Case Study Trend Main Highlight (Wilson et Centralized fisheries Centralized Need , 2.
management in Lake management awareness in fisheries Malawi Mbenji Island.
Malawi (Wahyono Marginalization of Rights of coastal Need for rights-based and Illiyani, coastal communities on communities the island of Bras, (RBFM) Croatia (UrsiN et al.
Female perspective on Significant trend in Reimagining island development increasing tourism female perspective (Teniwut et Knowledge management Development of Three critical factors:
, 2.
capabilities related to knowledge technology, organizational marine and fisheries management structure, organizational resources in Southeast capabilities Maluku.
Indonesia (Suh, 2.
Case of the AoFull of Grace Community-based Government's Organic Agriculture organic agriculture promoting ProducersAo cooperative in (CBOA) the Philippines (Sok and Yu.
Co-management of Co-management of Community participation small-scale fishery in small-scale fisheries and satisfaction levels Tonle Sap Lake.
Cambodia (Schwarz et Adaptive co- Community-based Importance , 2.
management in small- resource scale fisheries in the management Solomon Islands (CBRM) Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
No.
Reference (Romero Manrique de Lara Corral, (Reynolds et , 2.
(Remling Veitayaki, (Prodhan et , 2.
CBM Case Study Artisanal community on the Island of Tenerife.
Spain Trend Socio-economic small island fishing Main Highlight Necessity for participatory research and improved Feasibility anaerobic digestion (AD) plant installation in the Orkney Islands.
United Kingdom Community's proactive resource management on Gau Island.
Fiji Waste-to-resource Feasibility of an anaerobic digestion (AD) plant Community-based adaptation (CBA) Salinity Parulia Union.
Bangladesh Philippine Successfully adapted by salinity intrusion due to shrimp farming Community-based co-management (CBCM) Importance Adaptation strategies by Coral reef management socio-economic dimensions in Jayapura.
Indonesia Effectiveness management practices in the Nicobar Islands Sustainability index (PrietoCarolino et , 2.
(Paulangan et al.
, 2.
(Patankar et , 2.
(Nwankwo et al.
, 2018.
Patankar et , 2.
(Murhaini Achmadi, (Molina.
Role heritage resources in within rural Nigeria Farming practices of the Dayak people in Kalimantan.
Indonesia Collective action among Gigantes Islands.
Philippines (Kruse , 2.
Islam.
, et , 2.
Ecosystem Status Report (ESR) framework in the Bering Sea and Aleutian Islands.
Alaska Region Maritime Vancouver Island.
Canada FishersAo and collaboration with local government units and stakeholders Need management strategies Need Community management and through heritage Sustainable farming Importance of traditional institutions in managing Promoting resilience Necessity evaluation of crab Resilience Convergence strategy with Importance of preserving resources for community Cultural significance of rice and the social dimensions in agricultural practices Importance of integrating ecosystem considerations into fisheries management Importance of developing Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
No.
Reference (Delgado et , 2.
CBM Case Study Role of managing water supply and participation of rural households on Chiloy Island.
Chile (Corral and Manrique de Lara, 2.
Artisanal communities on the Island Tenerife.
Canary Islands (Casola et , 2.
(Basel et al.
Artisanal communities on Andros Island.
The Bahamas Community-based adaptation planning on Rendova Island, the Solomon Islands Trend Governance water management Socio-economic challenges to local coastal and marine Effects fishing communities Local Main Highlight Conceptual models Importance of integrating local fishing communities decision-making Effects for both positive and negative outcomes Community priorities for adaptation: governance, resource management The management of isolated islands through community-based methods is increasingly recognized, as evidenced by research recommendations based on robust and valid methods.
Data analysis synthesizes trends and highlights, justifying integrative and adaptive problem-solving.
Table 5 and Figure 6 .
show the types of methods used in CBM research: a mixed methods approach, a qualitative method, and a specific analysis approach.
A mixed methods approach combines qualitative and quantitative research techniques in one study to produce a deeper, more comprehensive understanding of the research problem (Sedegah et al.
, 2.
Several papers in this review study have successfully carried out this approach, providing more in-depth solution recommendations (Prodhan et al.
, 2017.
Sok and Yu, 2021.
Teniwut et al.
, 2017.
Wilson et al.
, 2.
Qualitative methods focus on exploring phenomena in depth by capturing the meaning and experiences of respondents without emphasizing measurement and statistical analysis .
uantitative method.
(Sedegah et al.
In this study, the percentage of researchers who used a qualitative method was much higher than the percentage of researchers who used a specific method approach.
In the context of CBM on isolated islands, qualitative methods can provide rich contextual insights into community perceptions, values, and practices.
In addition, specific analysis approaches can assess case study issues that are more relevant and appropriate to the researcher's needs for justification, such as the participatory technique in Figure 6 .
Figure 6.
Types of methods used in the research of CBM.
Methodological framework of the participatory techniques (Corral and Manrique de Lara, 2017.
Romero Manrique de Lara and Corral.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
One of the main highlights from the literature review is the need to integrate local knowledge into natural resource conservation practices.
Researchers report the importance of incorporating local knowledge and practices into natural resource management (Basel et al.
, 2020.
Nwankwo et al.
, 2018.
Patankar et al.
, 2.
This is also supported by the findings of the researchersAo study which emphasized the need for open communication through participatory discussions to ensure the success of management strategies (Delgado et al.
, 2021.
Molina, 2018.
Wahyono and Illiyani, 2.
isolated islands, ecosystems are usually fragile due to the impact of external pressures, so natural resource management practices based on local wisdom have the potential to produce management practices that are more appropriate and in line with community values (Casola et al.
, 2021.
Corral and Manrique de Lara, 2017.
Kruse et al.
, 2.
In addition, studies on trends and main highlights also highlight aspects of agroindustry that have not been widely studied but have a significant impact on communities in isolated islands.
This is like the potential for supply chain management for food security and marketing of natural resource products reported by Islam.
, et al.
, .
and strengthening upstream to downstream production design in local wisdom-oriented resource management (Prodhan et al.
, 2017.
Remling and Veitayaki.
The potential of supply chain management will be a great start for fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) businesses (Trihatmoko et al.
, 2.
Other research also has the potential to improve the welfare of communities on isolated islands, such as tourism development (UrsiN et al.
, 2.
and waste management (Reynolds et al.
, 2.
The justification for problem-solving in almost every research paper is explained as a specific problem related to a comprehensive understanding of the local context and the synergy of collective actions.
Based on the SDG framework, some papers discussed the localization of the SDGs, which involves tailoring the SDGs to island-specific governance, culture, and environment through local engagement.
The quality of the evidence can be found in all the research papers that discuss a specific problem trend and elaborate on a fundamental theory to justify problemsolving.
The recent trends are classified by methods and justification for problem-solving, as shown in Table 5.
No.
Table 5.
Recent trends in methods and justification for problem-solving Reference Trend Method Justification for problem-solving (Wilson et Centralized Mixed methods The study moves beyond merely , 2.
technical solutions to include (Wahyono Rights of coastal Qualitative method In-depth understanding of the and Illiyani, communities socio-cultural (UrsiN et al.
Significant trend Thematic analysis Grounded in existing theoretical increasing approach of participants' experiences and perspectives (Teniwut et Development of Mixed methods Providing , 2.
(Suh, 2.
CommunityQualitative The method is relevant and organic method adaptable to local conditions, (CBOA) collective actions (Sok and Yu.
Co-management Mixed methods Allowed for a robust collection of small-scale approach data, providing a well-rounded understanding of issues at hand Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
No.
Reference (Schwarz et , 2.
Trend Communitybased (CBRM) Method Participatory (Romero Manrique de Lara Corral, (Reynolds et , 2.
Socio-economic development of Waste-toresource Communitybased adaptation (CBA) Qualitative method
Successfully salinity intrusion due to shrimp
Communitybased (CBCM) Mixed The study captures a holistic view
adaptation strategies Qualitative method
RAPSOCIOECOSYSTEM
method: modified version of Rapid
Appraisal
Fisheries Approach
(RAPFISH),
Qualitative method Comprehensive understanding of issues and to propose solutions, leveraging strengths of community Multidimensional necessary for addressing the complex issues of coral reef ecosystem management (Remling Veitayaki, (Prodhan et , 2.
(PrietoCarolino et , 2.
(Paulangan et al.
, 2.
Sustainability index values (Patankar et , 2.
(Nwankwo et al.
, 2.
(Murhaini Achmadi, (Molina.
Need comparing three Community management and through heritage Sustainable farming practices Promoting development in Techno-economic Qualitative method Descriptive survey and ethnographic Qualitative method Institutionalization of a convergence Justification for problem-solving Management solutions tailored to fit the local governance context and informed by multiple knowledge sources, fostering local ownership and participation Comprehensive problem-solution relationship analysis, fostering a sustainable fisheries management This approach helps in evaluating the feasibility of the investment opportunity and addresses the problem of waste management Comprehensive understanding of local contexts and priorities Need to evaluate effectiveness of traditional management systems in the Nicobar Islands The study captures both the measurable effect of heritage resources and nuanced, culturally embedded practices Particularly effective in problemsolving: helps identify cultural and social factors that influence farming Collectively resilience building in the islands Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
No.
Reference (Kruse et al.
(Islam.
, et , 2.
(Delgado et , 2.
(Corral and Manrique de Lara, 2.
(Casola , 2.
(Basel et al.
Trend Necessity evaluation of crab Resilience maritime supply Governance Socio-economic development and local coastal and marine resources Effects modernization on artisanal fishing Local knowledge Method Ecosystem-based (EBFM) approach Case practical reasons.
research design Mixed Justification for problem-solving Robust framework for addressing multifaceted challenges of fisheries decisions are informed by a comprehensive understanding Detailed understanding of underresearched topics by incorporating multiple sources of evidence Collectively integrating social, ecological, and political perspectives to address complex challenges Qualitative method Collectively enhance decisionmaking process and empower local communities to participate actively in managing their resources Qualitative method The study is able to address gaps in previous research that often relied on outsider viewpoints Modified Local Early Action Planning (LEAP) methodology and a semi-quantitative The analysis that is both scientifically rigorous and locally relevant, increasing likelihood of identifying effective adaptation priorities Most researchers use field surveys to collect data.
These surveys may include interviews, focus group discussions, household surveys, direct participation, and triangulated research designs.
This literature review examined community-based management (CBM) using a case study of an isolated island or rural area.
The findings are presented in a three-phase framework research paper pattern, as shown in Figure 8: input, process, and output.
Based on the literature review, researchers attempted to bridge the gap between academic theory and community issues and needs by identifying socioeconomic conditions, as demonstrated in Table 7 and Figure 9.
Researchers adjust their analyses to the research methods used in the data analysis process.
Furthermore, when using a mixed methods approach, researchers conduct qualitative research through interviews and literature studies, as well as statistical tests.
For example.
Teniwut et al.
performed a hierarchical regression test using SPSS 24 (Teniwut et al.
, 2.
Additionally, researchers using qualitative methods have valid and reliable data analysis methods that are adjusted to the needs of the research, the conditions of the field, and the characteristics of the data.
For example.
Murhaini and Achmadi .
conducted qualitative research with data analysis using a coding process guided by Kroeber and Kluckhohn's cultural cycle approach (Murhaini and Achmadi, 2.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
Figure 8.
Overview of research framework Community-based management (CBM) research aims to solve community problems through academic inquiry.
Therefore, paying attention to the research framework is important for conducting good research.
Based on a literature review, researchers have attempted to bridge the gap between academic theory and community issues and needs by identifying socioeconomic conditions, as illustrated in Table 7 and Figure 9.
Figure 9.
Mind map of community-based management (CBM) based on paper review results Based on the literature review, researchers attempted to bridge the gap between academic theory and community issues and needs by narrowing their research focus and employing relevant This makes research findings more easily accepted and applied by communities in isolated Examples include the long-term success of the Mbenji Island fisheries (Wilson et al.
, 2.
unique cooperative of artisanal producers (Manrique de Lara and Corral, 2.
and community-based knowledge sharing (Teniwut et al.
, 2.
Table 7 provides a classification of relevant studies for CBM and socio-economic conditions.
Table 7.
Relevance studies from classification for CBM and socio-economic conditions Reference Method Data Collection Socio-economic Conditions (Wilson et al.
Mixed methods Archival oral Long-term success of Mbenji environmental Island fisheries (Wahyono and Qualitative method Interviews and observations Not mentioned Illiyani, 2.
(UrsiN et al.
Thematic analysis Interviews with both snowball Capital framework to identify and convenience sampling socio-cultural, economic (Teniwut et al.
Mixed methods In-depth and Community-based (Suh, 2.
Qualitative Not mentioned Lack of economic incentives for CBOA.
suggests policy measures to address this Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
Reference (Sok and Yu.
Method Mixed (Schwarz et al.
Participatory Qualitative method (Romero Manrique Lara Corral, 2.
Data Collection Household informant interviews, group Household surveys, focus group discussions (FGD.
, secondary literature Participatory approach (Reynolds , 2.
(Remling and Veitayaki.
Techno-economic Qualitative method Online questionnaire (Prodhan et al.
Mixed Focus group discussions and key informant interviews (PrietoCarolino et al.
(Paulangan et , 2.
Qualitative method Face-to-face interviews, focus group discussions (FGD.
, key informant interviews Field surveys and in-depth (Patankar , 2.
(Nwankwo , 2.
(Murhaini and Achmadi, (Molina, 2.
(Kruse et al.
(Islam.
, et , 2.
(Delgado et al.
RAPSOCIOECOSYSTEM
Qualitative method Descriptive survey and ethnographic Qualitative method Institutionalization of a convergence Ecosystem-based (EBFM) approach Case practical reasons.
research design Mixed Qualitative fieldwork: semistructured interviews and Measuring fish abundance and biomass, recording all noncryptic fish species, semistructured interviews Cluster multistage sampling for the quantitative survey Direct observation, interviews, secondary data Participatory risk and capacity needs assessments Annual bottom trawl surveys Triangulated research design, documentation, site visits Literature semistructured interviews, rural household survey Socio-economic Conditions Need for improved resource sharing, capacity building, and law enforcement Necessity building among participants management practices.
Unique reduce operational costs Economic and social benefits of utilizing local waste Local ownership and selfdetermination, which are Need for further scientific studies and government support to ensure long-term sustainable solutions for affected communities Effectiveness of organized fishers in managing abalone resources sustainably Socio-economic contingent upon strong community institutions Not mentioned Not mentioned Significance of customary values and traditions in the Dayak peopleAos farming management system Not mentioned Importance of integrating into stock assessments Several resilience strategies to mitigate effect of future maritime logistics Need for a multi-level Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
Reference Method Data Collection (Corral Manrique Lara, 2.
Qualitative method Stakeholder analysis, semistructured interviews, focus groups, workshops (Casola et al.
Qualitative method Interviews (Basel et al.
Modified Local Early Action Planning (LEAP) semi-quantitative Capturing information, semiquantitative assessment, interviews Socio-economic Conditions Socio-economic development of small-island particularly focusing on artisanal fishing sector Modernization globalization have resulted in overexploitation of natural Importance of inclusive and participatory processes in developing effective climate adaptation strategies The number of research articles discussing agroindustry studies on isolated islands is very low.
Researchers have found few research articles on the socio-economic development of agroindustry on isolated islands with an in-depth and comprehensive understanding.
This lack of articles on agroindustry studies is different from the topics of fisheries, agriculture, and social science, which are not difficult to This situation can lead to potential future research on the agroindustry that focuses on upstream and downstream connections being important for people on isolated islands.
Researchers have only conducted studies on supply chain management in communities on isolated islands.
Krisnaningsih et .
reported the importance of a decision support system to optimize supply chain conditions on isolated islands.
Kusnandar et al.
found that the participation of all actors in the supply chain plays an important role in achieving sustainable change in agroindustrial, with the proposal of Participatory Sustainable Agricultural Development, which can be implemented by involving communities in such development.
Therefore, there is little research on agroindustry .
ack of empirical suppor.
, and the location on an isolated island is an overlooked study area.
In addition to fisheries, agriculture, and social science that have been widely studied.
CBM for the development of socioeconomic agroindustry on an isolated island should potentially become another perspective for comparison in viewing a problem.
Based on the literature review, the potential of agroindustry in community-based management on remote islands is relevant and plays several important roles.
First, in terms of economic development, agroindustry can stimulate economic growth on isolated islands by creating jobs and increasing local income.
For example.
Mardesci et al.
found that developing a coconut-based agroindustry in Indonesia has proven effective in providing jobs and increasing the value of coconut Second, in terms of food security, agroindustry can increase food security on remote islands by establishing facilities and improving food processing skills (Rizkina et al.
, 2.
, enabling communities to reduce their dependence on food products from outside the islands, which are often subject to weather and sea conditions.
Agroindustry also has the potential to contribute to food availability and economic stability (Abildtrup, et al.
, 2012.
Rizkina et al.
, 2.
Additionally, in terms of sustainable resource management, agroindustry can utilize local resources efficiently through sustainable practices, such as minimizing waste.
For instance, increasing the value of agricultural byproducts can mitigate environmental impact (Murtius, 2.
This aligns with the local wisdom of isolated islands, which helps preserve ecosystems and biodiversity while supporting the local economy.
Then, community empowerment and community-based management in the agroindustry sector will involve community contributions to foster a sense of shared ownership and responsibility for resource According to Fahmi et al.
, community involvement in agroindustry can increase Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
social cohesion and empower local residents.
This is particularly relevant for isolated islands, where strong community ties and collective action can lead to more effective resource management.
Finally, technological innovation and the introduction of new technologies can adapt to the community's needs, increasing productivity and efficiency.
Examples include the use of digital devices in agricultural practices (Medvedskaya et al.
, 2.
Methods as steps or procedures for conducting research, are an important part of research.
Based on the literature review of CBM on isolated islands, qualitative methods and specific methods are the most widely used.
Mixed methods are the least used, even though it is effective in providing an indepth and comprehensive understanding compared with other types of methods.
Therefore, researchers should be able to use mixed methods to explore problems more deeply through qualitative research and draw valid conclusions and reliable generalizations through quantitative research.
Community-based management involves community contributions to foster a sense of shared ownership and responsibility for resource management.
The study of community-based management is also still considered to be limited in examining isolated island case studies.
Most research only discusses case studies of rural areas, whereas isolated island case studies need to be given attention because some problems are essential.
Therefore, future research is expected to pay attention to isolated island case studies to reduce a concern problem, such as poverty, as the number one sustainable development goal (SDG).
The SDG framework adopted the 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDG.
as part of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
The SDGs aim to promote human well-being, environmental conservation, and the sustainable management of natural resources.
To support these goals, community-based management in isolated communities can be a new research objective.
However, little research exists on interdisciplinary discussions of CBM, which are necessary for isolated communities as vulnerable objects.
In addition, fisheries are a major focus of CBM-related research because they are fundamental to the economic development of isolated islands.
The community depends on fisheries and marine products for food security and business.
The same is true for agriculture, which is also a major concern in CBM-related research.
However, research gaps can be found in the SDGs on agroindustry, which are under-researched in island contexts.
Therefore, this innovative research and robust methodology can provide proper policies and precise practical recommendations, particularly for governments and NGOs working in island contexts.
CONCLUSIONS
The study highlights novel contributions to research papers over the past ten years.
It shows that CBM applications continue to focus on integrating local wisdom through the participation of all stakeholders, such as community members and government officials.
CBM studies primarily employ observation, interviews, focus group discussions, surveys, and literature reviews to collect data.
The evaluation of CBM study data should align more closely with the mixed methods approach, which is rarely used.
The study also suggests reducing the gap between academic theory and community needs by examining methods that provide a deeper, more comprehensive understanding for future research directions, according to field conditions.
Our review's results show that 39% of studies still use specific methods, which is this review's unique contribution.
Additionally, future research is expected to explore topics that have not been widely studied, such as agroindustry in isolated island contexts.
This finding is reflected in the percentage of CBM review results on isolated islands: agroindustry studies represent only 9%, while fisheries represent 52%, social sciences represent 22%, and agriculture represents The study suggests that future research based on an in-depth exploration of CBM topics in isolated island contexts can provide specific, practical implications for policymakers through robust methodologies such as mixed-methods approaches in agroindustry.
This approach will help policymakers analyze decision-making based on comprehensive data.
Rizkina et al.
/Agroindustrial Journal Vol.
12 No.
REFERENCES