Maria Wuri Handayani.
Leonnard Ong / Beyond Innovation: Relational Capabilities as Drivers of Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty in Industrial SME Markets / 94-101 e-ISSN: 2747-0040 | p-ISSN: 2715-5080 Vol.
8 | No.
1 (May 2.
Beyond Innovation: Relational Capabilities as Drivers of Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty in Industrial SME Markets Maria Wuri HandayaniA*.
Leonnard Ong A AA IPMI Institute.
Kalibata.
Jakarta.
Indonesia
ABSTRACT
ARTICLEINFO
Marketing innovation is commonly regarded as a key driver of however, its effectiveness may vary across different market settings.
In Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (SME.
ecosystems, where long-term collaboration and interdependence are central, relational capabilities may play a more decisive role than innovation-driven differentiation.
This research focuses on how Strategic Marketing Innovation.
Service Quality, and SME Empowerment influence Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty.
Drawing on the Resource-Based View and Relationship Marketing Theory, it explores whether relational capabilities provide a stronger foundation for brand development than innovation-oriented strategies.
Data were collected from 200 SME customers within the industrial flour supply chain in Java.
Indonesia, and analyzed using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM).
The results show that Strategic Marketing Innovation does not significantly affect Brand Equity, whereas SME Empowerment and Service Quality have significant positive effects.
Brand Equity, in turn, strongly influences Customer Loyalty.
These results imply that relational qualities, rather than just innovation intensity, are more important in determining brand success and customer loyalty in partnership-oriented industrial They also emphasize how crucial relational techniques are to bolstering community-based industrial ecosystems and SME Article History:
Received : 26 Ae 04 Ae 2026 Revised : 14 Ae 05 Ae 2026 Accepted : 20 Ae 05 Ae 2026 Published : 29 Ae 05 Ae 2026 Keywords:
Relational capabilities SME Empowerment Service quality Brand Equity Customer Loyalty Community Development JEL: M31.
L25.
M19 *Corresponding Author E-mail:
handayani@ipmi.
Copyright A 2026 Authors.
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC-BY-SA 4.
which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited & ShareAlike terms followed.
- 94 -
Journal of Sustainable Community Development Vol.
8 No.
1 (May, 2.
INTRODUCTION limited attention in branding and SME research.
In many SME-driven industrial markets, sustaining competitive advantage is not as straightforward as it appears.
Firms often operate in environments where price competition is intense and product differentiation is limited, making it difficult to rely solely on traditional competitive strategies.
This study is particularly relevant to SME development since it shows how service quality and empowerment affect both the sustainability of SME ecosystems and business performance.
While innovation has long been considered a key driver of firm performance, its actual impact may depend heavily on how well it aligns with customer needs and operational realities.
In practice.
SME customers tend to prioritize reliability, consistency, and business continuity over novelty.
At the same time, relational aspects such as service quality and ongoing engagement are increasingly recognized as critical factors in shaping long-term Recent studies in SME and industrial contexts also indicate that innovation, service quality, and relational engagement are often examined separately, resulting in limited understanding of their combined impact on brand equity and customer loyalty (Iglesias, et al.
, 2.
(Adriel, et al.
, 2.
Theoretical Foundation LITERATURE STUDY The Resource-Based View (RBV) posits that firms achieve sustained competitive advantage through resources that are valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-substitutable ( (Barney, 1.
(Peteraf, 1.
While early RBV research emphasized technological and innovation-based resources, recent studies suggest that relational capabilities, such as service quality and customer engagement, constitute equally critical strategic assets, particularly in business-to-business contexts (Kurniawan, et al.
, 2.
This perspective is further strengthened by the dynamic capability view, which highlights the firmAos ability to reconfigure resources in response to changing environments (Teece, et al.
, 1.
This issue becomes particularly important in the context of PT Sriboga Flour Mill, where SME customers act not only as buyers but also as end-consumer In addition, the commitment-trust theory of relationship marketing emphasizes that long-term business relationships are built upon trust and commitment, which are critical drivers of customer loyalty (Morgan & Hunt, 1.
In industrial SME ecosystems, these relational mechanisms play an essential role in translating firm capabilities into sustained performance outcomes.
Drawing on the Resource-Based View (RBV) and Customer-Based Brand Equity (CBBE) theory, this study proposes that brand equity serves as a central mechanism linking firm capabilities to customer loyalty.
Specifically, this research focuses on how strategic marketing innovation, service quality, and SME empowerment influence brand equity, which subsequently drives customer Complementing this perspective.
Customer-Based Brand Equity (CBBE) theory explains how firmlevel capabilities are translated into customer perceptions, which subsequently drive behavioral outcomes such as loyalty (Keller, 1.
industrial SME ecosystems, where customers act as both buyers and intermediaries, brand equity becomes a key mechanism linking operational capabilities to downstream market performance.
This study contributes to the literature in three First, it brings together innovation, service, and empowerment within a single capability Second, it highlights the role of brand equity as a central strategic asset in a Business-toBusiness-to-Consumer (B2B2C) SME context, connecting firm capabilities with customer Third, it offers empirical evidence from the Indonesian flour industry, which has received Strategic Marketing Innovation Strategic marketing innovation reflects a firmAos ability to introduce new marketing approaches and adapt to evolving market dynamics (Hurley & Hult, - 95 - Maria Wuri Handayani.
Leonnard Ong / Beyond Innovation: Relational Capabilities as Drivers of Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty in Industrial SME Markets / 94-101 While prior studies generally support its positive effect on firm performance (Kim & Lee.
, emerging evidence suggests that its effectiveness is context-dependent.
SME empowerment extends beyond transactional exchanges by positioning customers as strategic Through training, technical support, and capability development, firms enhance customersAo business performance, thereby strengthening relational bonds.
However, empirical findings remain mixed, as innovation does not always directly influence customer perception or brand evaluation (Dumitriu et al.
, 2.
In SME contexts, its effectiveness depends on alignment with operational and customer value creation processes (Rahmat, et al.
, 2.
SME empowerment has been shown to enhance trust, commitment, and long-term business sustainability, reinforcing its role as a strategic relational capability ( (Theresia, et al.
, 2.
(Widodo & Nugraha,D.
, 2.
In SME-driven industrial markets, where customers prioritize operational reliability and cost efficiency, innovation may not directly translate into stronger brand perceptions.
This indicates a potential boundary condition of RBV, where innovation alone may be insufficient without alignment to customer value creation From an RBV perspective, empowerment can be conceptualized as a market-facing capability that creates value not only within the firm but also across its customer network (Conger & Kanungo.
, 1.
This relational embeddedness increases switching costs and reinforces brand attachment, making empowerment a potentially stronger driver of brand equity than traditional marketing H1: Strategic Marketing Innovation positively influences Brand Equity.
H3: SME Empowerment positively influences Brand Equity.
Service Quality Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty Service quality has long been recognized as a fundamental driver of customer satisfaction and trust (Parasuraman, et al.
, 1.
In relational market settings, particularly B2B SME ecosystems, consistent service delivery reduces uncertainty and strengthens long-term partnerships.
Brand equity represents customersAo overall evaluation of a brand based on their experiences and perceptions ( (Aaker, 1.
(Keller, 1.
B2B2C contexts.
SME customers act as intermediaries who transfer brand value to end consumers, amplifying the strategic importance of brand equity.
Recent studies also confirm that service quality strengthens brand credibility and trust, particularly in industrial service ecosystems ( (Raddats, et al.
, 2.
(Taufik, et al.
, 2.
Prior research consistently shows that brand equity serves as a key antecedent of customer loyalty (Oliver, 1.
Rather than being directly influenced by operational capabilities, loyalty is often mediated by customersAo perception of brand Unlike differentiation, service quality operates as a stabilizing mechanism that reinforces brand Empirical evidence suggests that service quality contributes to brand equity indirectly by shaping customer experiences and relational trust (Aesterina & Ong.
, 2.
H4: Brand Equity positively influences Customer Loyalty.
RESEARCH METHOD
H2: Service Quality positively influences Brand Equity.
A quantitative explanatory approach is used in this study to examine the relationships among Strategic Marketing Innovation.
Service Quality.
SME SME Empowerment - 96 - Journal of Sustainable Community Development Vol.
8 No.
1 (May, 2.
Empowerment.
Brand Equity, and Customer Loyalty.
relational capability studies.
Brand Equity was measured using Customer-Based Brand Equity (CBBE) dimensions derived from (Keller, 1.
and (Aaker, 1.
, while Customer Loyalty indicators were adapted from (Oliver, 1.
All measurement items were adjusted to fit the SMEbased industrial flour supply chain context.
Data were collected from 200 SME customers of PT Sriboga Flour Mill across Java.
Indonesia.
Purposive sampling was employed to target business owners and managers who actively purchase and utilize the companyAos products in their operations.
This sampling technique was considered appropriate because the study required respondents with direct experience and understanding of the variables under investigation, long-term partnerships in the flour supply chain.
The sample size was considered adequate for PLS-SEM analysis, which is suitable for complex models and moderate sample sizes (Hair, et al.
, 2.
To assess potential common method bias (CMB), a collinearity test was conducted using Variance Inflation Factor (VIF).
All VIF values were below the conservative threshold of 3.
3, indicating that common method bias is not a significant concern.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Measurement Model Assessment The satisfactory reliability and validity.
All indicator loadings exceed the recommended threshold of 70, confirming indicator reliability (Hair, et al.
Composite reliability (CR) values are above 70, indicating strong internal consistency, while Average Variance Extracted (AVE) values exceed 50, confirming convergent validity.
The study employs Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM) using SmartPLS 4.
This method is appropriate due to its ability to handle non-normal data distributions and predictive-oriented models.
All constructs were measured using reflective indicators adapted from established prior studies.
Strategic Marketing Innovation was adapted from (Hurley & Hult, 1.
and (Kim & Lee.
, 2.
Service Quality was measured based on the SERVQUAL (Service Qualit.
developed by (Parasuraman, et al.
, 1.
SME
Empowerment indicators were adapted from (Conger & Kanungo.
, 1.
and recent SME Discriminant validity was assessed using the Heterotrait-Monotrait Ratio (HTMT).
Although several construct pairs approach the threshold of 90, this reflects conceptual proximity rather than measurement issues, which is acceptable in theorydriven models.
Table 1.
Measurement Model Evaluation Construct
Indicator Loadings CronbachAos Alpha
SMI
731 Ae 0.
896 Ae 0.
886 Ae 0.
863 Ae 0.
913 Ae 0.
Structural Model Assessment
AVE
Additionally, effect size analysis shows that SME Empowerment has a moderate effect on Brand Equity, while Service Quality has a small effect, and Strategic Marketing Innovation has a negligible Brand Equity demonstrates a very strong The model explains 66.
9% of the variance in Brand Equity and 78.
1% in Customer Loyalty, indicating substantial explanatory power.
- 97 -
Maria Wuri Handayani.
Leonnard Ong / Beyond Innovation: Relational Capabilities as Drivers of Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty in Industrial SME Markets / 94-101 effect on Customer Loyalty.
Table 2.
Structural Model Results Hypothesis Path t-value p-value Result SMI Ie BE 0.
>0.
Not Supported SQ Ie BE <0.
Supported SE Ie BE <0.
Supported BE Ie CL <0.
Supported Interestingly, the findings reveal that strategic marketing innovation does not significantly influence brand equity in this context.
This result may seem counterintuitive at first, given the strong emphasis on innovation in the existing literature.
However, in SME-based industrial markets, customers are often more concerned with practical value than with novelty.
From a managerial perspective, this finding reflects the operational realities of SME-based industrial markets.
B2B contexts is built gradually through reliable interactions rather than one-off initiatives.
SME empowerment shows the strongest influence on brand equity, suggesting that capability development at the customer level plays a critical role in shaping brand perception.
Unlike innovation, which may remain abstract, empowerment is directly experienced by customers, making its impact more visible and meaningful in daily operations.
One possible explanation is that innovation, when not directly linked to operational benefits, may not be sufficiently visible or meaningful to customers.
This finding reinforces the idea that innovation alone is not always enough to shape customer perception, particularly in relationally embedded Finally, the strong relationship between brand equity and customer loyalty reinforces its role as a central mechanism linking firm capabilities to behavioral outcomes.
Rather than responding directly to firm initiatives, customers appear to base their loyalty on how they perceive the overall value of the brand.
The findings offer several important insights into how capabilities translate into customer outcomes in SME-driven industrial markets.
Contribution This study offers four key contributions to the A notable result is the non-significant effect of strategic marketing innovation on brand equity.
Although innovation is often positioned as a primary driver of competitive advantage, its impact in this context appears to be limited.
This may be explained by the nature of SME markets, where customers tend to prioritize operational reliability and tangible business benefits over In contrast, service quality emerges as a more stable and influential factor.
Consistent service delivery reduces uncertainty and strengthens trust, which are essential in long-term business This supports the view that value in - 98 - Reframing Brand Equity as a NetworkEmbedded Strategic Asset This study extends Customer-Based Brand Equity (CBBE) theory by conceptualizing brand equity as a network-embedded construct within B2B2C ecosystems.
SME intermediaries transmitting brand value to end consumers.
Identifying a Contextual Boundary Condition of Innovation Capability The findings challenge the universal Journal of Sustainable Community Development Vol.
8 No.
1 (May, 2.
innovation-driven competitive advantage by demonstrating that strategic marketing innovation does not significantly enhance brand equity in SME-driven industrial markets.
technical training, recipe standardization, and business coaching.
These programs enhance customer capability while increasing dependency and long-term
SME
SME
benefits not only firm-level outcomes but also larger community development.
Extending RBV through Relational and Market-Facing Capabilities This study advances the Resource-Based View by positioning SME empowerment as a relational, co-created capability that generates competitive advantage beyond firm boundaries.
Operationalize Service Quality as a System Level Capability Service quality should be standardized supported by clear service protocols and response systems.
Reliable service delivery becomes a key competitive advantage in price-sensitive markets.
Manage Brand Equity as a Strategic Retention Mechanism Firms should actively align marketing, service, and empowerment initiatives to strengthen brand equity.
Strong brand equity reduces price sensitivity and protects customer loyalty against competitive pressures.
Extending the Study toward MacroMarketing Perspectives.
Beyond firm-level implications, the findings also contribute to broader macromarketing perspectives by demonstrating how relational capabilities within SME ecosystems can strengthen economic resilience, collaborative value creation, community-based In emerging markets, relational mechanisms such as service support and SME empowerment may play an important role not only in improving firm performance, but also in fostering inclusive economic development across interconnected supply chain networks.
CONCLUSION
The results of this study highlight that, within SMEbased industrial markets, customer loyalty is more strongly shaped by relational capabilities than by innovation intensity alone.
While innovation remains relevant, its contribution appears to depend on how well it supports practical customer This reflects the realities of SME-based industrial markets, where relationships often matter more than differentiation.
Managerial Implications The findings provide strategic implications for firms operating in SME-driven industrial markets, particularly within the flour industry.
Redefine Innovation Strategy Toward Practical Value Creation Firms should shift from innovation for Marketing innovation initiatives must directly support SME productivity, cost efficiency, and product application.
From a managerial perspective, this suggests that firms may achieve more sustainable outcomes by strengthening relationships, building trust, and supporting customer development, rather than relying solely on innovation-driven differentiation.
Limitations and Future Research Institutionalize SME Empowerment as a Scalable Growth Platform SME empowerment should be embedded into structured programs, including This study has several limitations.
First, the study employed a cross-sectional design, which limits the ability to observe changes in customer perceptions - 99 - Maria Wuri Handayani.
Leonnard Ong / Beyond Innovation: Relational Capabilities as Drivers of Brand Equity and Customer Loyalty in Industrial SME Markets / 94-101 and loyalty over time.
Second, the study focused specifically on SME customers within the Indonesian flour supply chain, which may limit the generalizability of the findings to other industrial sectors or geographical contexts.
industries and emerging market ecosystems to consistently outperform innovation-oriented strategies in shaping brand equity and customer Longitudinal approaches may also provide deeper insights into the evolving dynamics of SME partnerships and relational value creation.
Future studies are encouraged to validate the proposed model in other B2B manufacturing Aaker.
, 1991.
Managing brand equity: Capitalizing on the value of a brand name.
New York: NY: Free Press.
Adriel.
Kim.
& Candra.
, 2024.
Digital engagement, relational trust, and customer loyalty in B2B contexts.
Journal of Business Research.
Volume 168.
, pp.
Aesterina.
& Ong.
, 2024.
The impact of e-service quality on e-satisfaction and loyalty in BTN Mobile: in the evidence of BTN Mobile banking users in Jabodetabek.
International Journal of Business Studies.
Volume 8.
, pp.
Barney.
, 1991.
Firm resources and sustained competitive advantage.
Journal of Management.
Volume 17.
, 99Ae120.
Conger.
& Kanungo.
, 1988.
The empowerment process: Integrating theory and practice.
Academy of Management Review.
Volume 13.
, p.
471Ae482.
Hair.
Hult.
Ringle.
& Sarstedt.
, 2022.
A primer on partial least squares structural equation modeling (PLS-SEM).
3rd ed.
Bandung: Thousand Oaks.
CA: Sage.
Hurley.
& Hult.
, 1998.
Innovation, market orientation, and organizational learning: An integration and empirical examination.
Journal of Marketing.
Volume 62.
, p.
42Ae54.
Iglesias.
Markovic.
S & Rialp.
, 2020.
How to build customer brand relationships in B2B contexts: The role of trust, commitment, and brand equity.
Volume 89, pp.
Keller.
, 1993.
Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing customer-based brand equity.
Journal of Marketing.
Volume 57.
, p.
1Ae22.
Kim.
& Lee.
, 2022.
Marketing innovation capability and firm performance: The moderating role of competitive intensity.
Journal of Business Research.
Volume 141, pp.
Kurniawan.
Basbeth.
& Ong.
, 2021.
Marketing Budgeting.
Marketing Activities and Distributor Loyalty:
the mediating effect of brand equity.
Conference Series.
Volume 3.
, pp.
Morgan.
& Hunt.
, 1994.
The commitmentAetrust theory of relationship marketing.
Journal of Marketing.
Volume 58.
, p.
20Ae38.
Oliver.
, 1999.
Whence consumer loyalty?.
Journal of Marketing.
Volume 63, p.
33Ae44.
Parasuraman.
Zeithaml.
& Berry.
, 1988.
SERVQUAL: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality.
Journal of Retailing.
Volume 64.
, p.
12Ae40.
- 100 -
Journal of Sustainable Community Development Vol.
8 No.
1 (May, 2.
Peteraf.
, 1993.
The cornerstones of competitive advantage: A resource-based view.
Strategic Management Journal.
Volume 14.
, p.
179Ae191.
Raddats.
Kowalkowski.
& Maull.
, 2024.
Service quality, trust, and brand credibility in industrial service Industrial Marketing Management.
Volume 117, pp.
Rahmat.
Setyawati.
& Rahman.
, 2024.
Evaluating the role of open innovation and circular economy in improving organizational performance: Insights from batik SMEs in Indonesia.
Sustainability.
Volume 16.
, pp.
Taufik.
Rahmawati.
& Pratama.
, 2022.
Service quality, emotional value, and brand credibility on customer loyalty in emerging markets.
Journal of Relationship Marketing.
Volume 21.
, pp.
Teece.
Pisano.
& Shuen.
, 1997.
Dynamic capabilities and strategic management.
Strategic Management Journal.
Volume 18.
, pp.
Theresia.
Andi.
& Nugroho.
, 2025.
SME empowerment and relational value creation in industrial supply Journal of Small Business Strategy.
Volume 35.
, p.
45Ae60.
Widodo.
& Nugraha.
, 2025.
SME empowerment and trust in B2B relationships: Pathways to sustainable business performance.
Journal of Small Business Management.
Volume 63.
, pp.
- 101 -