Cakrawala Pendidikan Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
https://journal.
id/index.
php/cp/issue/view/2348 DOI: https://doi.
org/10.
21831/cp.
Web-based instruments for national competences of physical education teachers Suroto1*.
Bayu Budi Prakoso1.
Anung Priambodo1.
Fifukha Dwi Khory1, and Vega Candra Dinata1 Universitas Negeri Surabaya.
Indonesia *Corresponding Author: suroto@unesa.
ABSTRACT
Several studies believe that the use of national standards as a benchmark for teacher quality can align education services to achieve national goals.
In addition, the number of years of teaching experience can determine teacher productivity during the course of their profession.
This article explores the results of developing a teacher competency measurement instrument based on the Indonesian national standards and evaluating teacher competency based on gender, grade, and working period.
To assess teacher competency, 277 Physical Education (PE) teachers completed an online survey at http://risetpjokindonesia.
The measurement results were analyzed using confirmatory factor analysis and Cronbach's alpha to test validity and reliability.
A T-test and one-way ANOVA were used to evaluate teacher competency based on gender, grade, and working period.
The findings show that the measurements are valid and reliable, allowing for their application in future research.
Gender, grade, and working period were found to affect teacher The development of teacher competency based on working period provides input in the form of accuracy in the teacherAos professional development and the limitation of the teacherAos productive period in carrying out his or her profession.
Keywords: web-based instrument, physical education, teacher, competency Article history Received:
3 May 2021 Revised:
2 June 2021 Accepted:
24 June 2022 Published:
1 October 2022 Citation (APA Styl.
: Suroto.
Prakoso.
Priambodo.
Khory.
, & Dinata.
Webbased instruments for national competences of physical education teachers.
Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan, 41.
, 742-753.
https://doi.
org/10.
21831/cp.
INTRODUCTION
Quality education is one of the focuses of the Sustainable Development Goals (United Nations, n.
Given the challenges in its education system.
Indonesia may be one of the contributors to the global problems in quality education.
It should be noted that the government of the Republic of Indonesia has shown its support for education by allocating 20% of the national budget to education since 2003 ( Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 20 of 2003 concerning the National Education System, 2.
The budget for education is focused on improving access and quality of education services in Indonesia (Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Indonesia, 2.
, but a large budget does not necessarily solve all problems in education.
The toughest problem Indonesia faces is the development of teacher competency .
edagogic, personality, social, and professiona.
, an initiative that began in 2005 ( Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 14 of 2005 concerning Teachers and Lecturers, 2.
The measurement of teacher competency has become the government's benchmark for providing incentives to teachers through the certification system.
Initially, the teacherAos portfolio system was chosen to measure teacher competency and was integrated with the certification system.
However, an obstacle arose in the form of document manipulation (Maksum, 2.
, which had an impact on the effectiveness of teacher certification programs.
Also, there was an absence of evidence for the effectiveness of teacher certification on student learning outcomes and teacher performance (Kusumawardhani.
Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
The Teacher Competency Test took its place of the Teacher Portfolio System in 2012 because the Teacher Portfolio System's accuracy in determining teacher competency had been too low since 2007.
The results of the test showed that the average teacher competency in Indonesia was below the national score targets (Team of Directorate General of Teachers and Education Staff, 2.
Under these conditions, the development of teacher competency in Indonesia is a cause for major concern.
Globally, the development of teacher competency is an important issue in education reform as it ensures the proper functioning of teachers in education services (PantiN & Wubbels, 2.
Competent teachers are the most important form of human capital for bringing Indonesia's national education system into line with those of developed countries(Yusof et al.
, 2.
Moreover, the impact of globalization at this time clearly presents extraordinary challenges in education, especially for developing countries (Akar, 2.
As a result, many countries do not adopt international standards as the benchmark for their education systems.
Instead, normative quality measures limited to the relative variations in each country are used, which do not perfectly adhere to international standards (Wagner & Castillo, 2.
Additionally, there are several disparities between the circumstances in developed and developing countries, especially those related to the level of education(Madsen, 2.
Therefore, it is appropriate to use national standards as the benchmark for teachers' professional development so that educational services are in line with national education goals (Klentschy, 2005.
Michael et al.
, 2.
This will affect the accuracy of teacher credentials in accordance with each nation's national standards(Liang et , 2005.
Nakai & Metzler, 2005.
Yoo & Kim, 2.
In order to support the appropriateness of teachers' compliance with national standards, it is logical if the national standard is used as the checklist of competencies as a measure of the teacher's self-quality (Brookhart, 2011.
Preston & Kennedy, 1.
Based on the explanation above, it is proposed that the first objective of this article is to explore the results of developing a teacher competency measurement instrument based on the Indonesian national standards, specifically for physical education teachers, by utilizing the Indonesian national standards for teacher competency.
The measurement model developed was a web-based checklist of competencies .
ttp://risetpjokindonesia.
com/).
The initial idea of developing teacher competency measurement, both independently and online, is to track the advancement of teacher competency, which has received little attention from the government (Saito & Van Cappelle, 2.
Although teachers use technology extensively (Huda et al.
, 2.
it has not yet been completely utilized for educational objectives in Indonesia (Wuryaningsih et , 2.
because teachers still frequently adhere to their conventional approaches to competency development (Sari, 2.
This gap really highlights the need for such measurements to be made so that teachers are accustomed to using information and communication technology for professional development.
The second objective of this research is to examine the qualifications of physical education teachers in relation to their gender, educational attainment, and years of teaching experience.
The productive periods of teachers follow their working periods, according to previous research, and teacher productivity assessments can be examined by considering six value-added models that comprise the most widely used criteria for determining teacher productivity (Harris & Sass, 2011.
Sass et al.
, 2.
Due to the fact that both studies were carried out in Florida.
USA, the findings may not apply to developing countries.
METHOD
This quantitative research was conducted using an online survey technique using the website http://risetpjokindonesia.
com/, developed by the Riset PJOK Indonesia team (Team for Physical Education Research in Indonesi.
The survey was distributed to teacher communities, academic institutions, and instructors who voluntarily responded on their own.
Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Participants Participating universities and teachers' communities signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) and committed to providing the venue and inviting teachers, including alumni from six universities (Universitas Negeri Surabaya.
Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama Sunan Giri Bojonegoro.
STKIP PGRI Jombang.
Universitas PGRI Banyuwangi.
Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha.
Universitas Cenderawasi.
Ae four universities (Universitas Negeri Surabaya.
Universitas Nahdlatul Ulama Sunan Giri Bojonegoro.
STKIP PGRI Jombang.
Universitas PGRI Banyuwang.
from the province of East Java representing Western Indonesia, one university (Universitas Pendidikan Ganesh.
from the province of Bali representing Central Indonesia, and one university (Universitas Cenderawasi.
from the province of Papua representing Eastern Indonesi.
Aior members of the teacher community to be participants.
The research team provided support in the form of socialization, workshops, and mentoring activities.
The number of participating PE teachers was 277 .
ee Table .
The age of participants ranged from 19 to 55 years (M = 34.
SD = 10.
The working period of participants ranged from Level 5: 0-5 years to Level 10: >25 years, with the most experienced participant having 36 years (M = 10.
SD = 9.
Table 1.
Basic information of the participants Parameter Total participants1 Gender Content Male Female Grade Elementary school Junior high school Senior high school Working period2 Level 5 = 0-5 years Level 6 = 6-10 years Level 7 = 11-15 years Level 8 = 16-20 years Level 9 = 21-25 years Level 10 = >25 years Retrieval of data in 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019* Level 1-4 is the level used for prospective PE teachers* Number Measure The instrument used is a questionnaire developed by the Riset PJOK Indonesia team that has been validated to measure the competency of PE teachers in Indonesia (Suroto, 2016.
Suroto et al.
, 2.
The instrument consists of 24 questions that are used to measure 24 core competencies for PE teachers.
Questions 1-10 measure pedagogic competence, questions 11-15 measure personality competence, questions 16-19 measure social competence, and questions 2024 measure professional competence ( Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 14 of 2005 concerning Teachers and Lecturers, 2005.
Regulation of the Minister of National Education of the Republic of Indonesia Number 18 of 2007 concerning Certification for Teachers in Position.
Each question has 4 to 6 answers, ranging from "never" to "always", and there is a column for the PE teacher to provide descriptions of empirical evidence to support the answers.
The instrument on http://risetpjokindonesia.
com is based on self-evaluation.
First, the subject (PE teache.
has to register for an account.
Upon admittance by the website administrator, the subject receives a user ID and password to access the website.
Next, the subject has to provide some data based on their residence ID card .
ull name.
Indonesia residential ID number, place of birth, and date of birt.
Then, the subject answers the questionnaire by choosing his or her answers and providing a description of empirical evidence to support the answers.
After completing the questionnaire, the score appears on the result cell.
The subjects may directly print the results or request a soft copy of the validation results.
Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Figure 1.
Example of Instrument Display Data analysis Subject matter experts (SME.
were used to assess content validity using AikenAos V as a formula to determine the degree of instrument validity (Aiken, 1980, 1985.
Sireci, 1.
Confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) was used to assess the validity of the measurement results.
The level of acceptance measures of the analysis results used are the fit model: KMO (> 0.
and Chi-Square .
<0.
loading factor> 0.
5 (Hair et al.
, 2014.
Ho, 2.
CronbachAos alpha was used to assess reliability with the provisions of alpha values> 0.
5 (Streiner, 2.
A descriptive statistical analysis was used to calculate the mean, standard deviation, skewness, kurtosis, and 1090 percentiles.
The level of acceptance skewness and kurtosis to determine the normal shape of the curve used was O 1 (Meyers et al.
, 2.
A T-test was used to assess the effect of gender on teacher competency, whereas a one-way ANOVA was used to assess the effect of work period on teacher competency.
FINDING AND DISCUSSION
Finding Initial validation of the teacher competency instrument The instrument used in this study was tested for content validity by professors who were subject matter experts (SME.
in teacher competency.
Analysis of test results was done using AikenAos V (Aiken, 1980.
Sireci, 1.
Each panelist declared the instrument valid for all the items tested.
Therefore, the count of each item was 1, and it could be concluded that the instrument was valid (Aiken, 1.
Totaling 277 teachers were requested to fill in the instrument .
ee Table .
The results of KMO (> 0.
and Chi-Square .
<0.
showed that the factor analysis met the modelAos adequacy value(Ho, 2.
The Eigenvalue scores that were formed in each analysis for each factor were greater than 1.
The loading values for each factor were as follows: 0.
, 824 .
, 0.
, 0.
, and 0.
otal The results of CronbachAos alpha of each component were as follows: 0857 .
, 0.
, 0.
, 0.
, 0.
otal competenc.
These results indicate that the instrument has sufficient reliability as an appropriate instrument (Streiner, 2.
Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Table 2.
Results of CFA for validity and CronbachAos Alpha for reliability Items/ Component Pedagogic Pedagogic-1 Pedagogic-2 Pedagogic-3 Pedagogic-4 Pedagogic-5 Pedagogic-6 Pedagogic-7 Pedagogic-8 Pedagogic-9 Pedagogic-10 Personality Personality-1 Personality-2 Personality-3 Personality-4 Personality-5 Social Social-1 Social-2 Social-3 Social-4 Professional Professional -1 Professional -2 Professional -3 Professional -4 Professional -5 Components Total Eigenvalue Variance (%) Variance accumulated (%) KMO Chi Square p-value CronbachAos Total Variance Explained KMO and Bartlett's Test Correlation matrix between components of PE teacher competency The correlation value between competency components was found to be significant .
<0.
The scores demonstrate that the four categories of teacher competency make up the entire competency value, as shown in Table 3.
Competency Profile for Physical Education TeachersAccording to descriptive statistics of the measurement findings, the data distribution is symmetric .
urtosis and skewness O.
The data distribution is hence normal (Meyers et al.
, 2.
The score categories are then established using percentiles from the descriptive statistics.
In Table 4, the mean total teacher competency of 7 is between the 40th and 50th percentiles, meaning that it is still in the moderate competency The pedagogical mean of 25.
1 is between the 50th and 60th percentiles, which further establishes its place in the category of good competency.
The personality mean of 13.
9 is between the 40th and 50th percentiles, meaning that it is still in the moderate competency category.
The social mean of 11.
7 is between the 40th and 50th percentiles, meaning that it is still in the moderate competency category.
The professional mean of 13.
0, which is in the 50th percentiles, is further classified in the moderate competency category.
Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Table 3.
Correlation matrix between components Component Pedagogic Personality Social Professional Total Pedagogic Personality Social Professional Total **.
Correlation is significant at the 0.
01 level.
Table 4.
Descriptive statistics on the competency scores of PE teachers Statistics Mean Std.
Dev.
Skewness Kurtosis Percentiles Score scale Pedagogic Personality Social Professional Total Effects of gender, working period, and grade on PE teacher competency Table 5 shows the effect of gender on teacher competency.
Gender differences were proven to have an influence on teacher competency in the pedagogical component .
= 2,142, p = .
, with female teachers scored higher for pedagogic competence compared to male teachers.
Table 5.
Effect of gender on teacher competency scores Independent Dependent Mean Variable Variable Difference Pedagogic Personality Gender:
Female (F) Social
Male (M) Professional Total
post hoc test based on Bonferroni Conclusiona
F>M
F=M
F=M
F=M
F=M
Table 6 shows the effect of working period and grade on teacher competency.
One-way ANOVA shows that working period level has an effect on total competence (F .
, .
= 5,023, p = 0,.
The post hoc Bonferroni tests showed that total competency at level 5 was lower than at level 6 .
= 0.
and 9 .
= 0.
The working period also affects the individual For example, pedagogic components (F .
, .
= 4,155, p = 0.
level 5, is lower than level 9 .
= 0.
, personality (F .
, .
= 4.
, p = 0.
level 5 is lower than level 9 .
= 0.
, social (F .
, .
= 4,142, p = 0.
level 5 is lower than level 6 .
= 0.
and level 9 .
= 0.
, and professional (F .
, .
= 4.
001, p = 0.
level 5 is lower than level 9 .
= 0.
Meanwhile, grade of school affects professional competence (F= 5.
205, p= 0.
and total competence (F= 3.
523, p= 0.
as elementary school teachersAo professional competence is lower than those in junior high school.
Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Table 6.
Effect of working period and grade on teacher competency Dependent Mean Independent Variable Variable Square Pedagogic Personality Working period1 Social Professional Conclusiona lvl 5<9 lvl 5<9 lvl 5<6.
lvl 5<9 lvl 5<6.
Total Pedagogic Personality Social Grade2 Professional Total 0-5 year= level 5.
6-10 year= level 6.
11-15 year= level 7.
16-20 year= level 8.
21-25 year= level 9.
>25 year= level 10 Elementary school= 1.
Junior high school= 2.
Senior high school= 3 Post hoc test based on bonferroni Personality Pedagogic Social Professional Figure 2.
Changes in Mean Teacher Competency Component Based on Working Period Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
Figure 3.
Changes in Mean Teacher Competency Based on Working Period Figures 2 and 3 show the four phases of changing teacher competency conditions.
First, there was an increasing trend in the initial period of becoming a teacher .
-5 year.
second, there was no development of teacher competence .
-20 year.
third, there was a sharp increase .
-25 and fourth, there was a significant decrease when retirement approached (> 25 year.
Discussion Based on the findings, the research objectives can be explained in two stages, namely .
the results of developing a teacher competency measurement instrument based on the Indonesian national standards and .
evaluating teacher competency based on gender, grade, and working period.
Based on the results of data analysis, it can be shown that the instrument has sufficient content validity.
The results of the CFA analysis show that the factor loading value of each item is in the range of values 0.
824, and the loading factor in the measurement component is in the range of 0.
These values are greater than 0.
4, so it can be concluded that the instrument has valid construct validity (Hair et al.
, 2.
In addition, the correlation matrix (Table .
shows that the competency component composed of each measurement item has a positive and significant correlation in compiling the teacher's final score.
The CronbachAos alpha values for components are in the range of 0.
857, while the total value of 0.
85 indicates that this instrument is reliable (Streiner, 2.
Descriptive statistics show that the distribution curve tends to tilt to the left .
egative skewness and kurtosi.
, meaning that the teacher's competency scores still tend to be below the average scores across Indonesia (Meyers et al.
, 2.
The average value of 63.
7 is between the 40th and50th percentiles, meaning that it is still in the moderate This shows that teachers in Indonesia are still lacking in competency, which is a common characteristic for teachers in developing countries (Yusof et al.
, 2.
This finding does not justify the current conditions but provides a basis for further development of teacher The second purpose of this article is to analyze the competency of physical education teachers based on gender, grade, and years of working experience as PE teachers.
Based on gender, female teacher competency is proven to be higher than male teacher competency.
This is different from the results of other previous studies by Dowling, which concluded that gender is not an important consideration in determining quality, and that both male and female teachers are considered equally competent (Dowling, 2.
Unfortunately, the findings of this article show that the number of female PE teachers is relatively lower compared to the number of male PE This is due to the assumption that physical activity and sports are related to masculinity (Lentillon et al.
, 2.
A possible explanation for higher competency scores in female teachers is that, being the minority, they have to raise their quality so they can continue to exist and be recognized alongside the majority of male teachers.
Teacher competency based on grade shows that teachers at higher levels are considered to be more competent than teachers at lower levels.
However, this condition does not occur Middle school teachers are considered to be better than elementary school teachers.
This Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
condition can be further discussed based on the leadership styles of school principals and school policies at each different grade level (Song, 2.
Based on the results of other studies by Youngs and King, it is seen that differences in school policies and the leadership styles of principals are believed to be important variables in the process of implementing professional development programs for teachers (Youngs & King, 2.
These differences can affect teacher participation in professional development programs and create further implications for the results of teacher participation in professional development programs (Kim & Lee, 2.
Thus, differences in teacher quality occur not just because of the grade of the school but also due to differences in school policy and the leadership style of the principal.
Teacher competency based on working period shows that a teacherAos working period influences teacher competency.
In Figure 3, the surge in teacher competency occurs in the early years of work .
However, static conditions occur during the 10Ae20-year work period, as if the teacher's competency does not further develop.
The next surge occurred in the 20Ae25-year work period, and after 25 years of work, teacher competency declined.
The results of this study are similar to other studies, which explain that teacher quality is influenced by working period especially during the first 5 years of work (Sass et al.
, 2.
, which then continues for the next 10 years (Harris & Sass, 2.
The results of this study indicate that there are limits on the productive age of teachers in carrying out their profession, which is 0-25 years.
The provision of treatment for the development of teacher competency throughout this time is essential in light of the static competency conditions in the 10Ae20-year employment period.
The findings of this article provide complementary support to the development of teacher competency programs based on national standards, especially in the context of measuring PE teacher competencies.
The measurement of teacher competency based on national standards in Indonesia is very precise.
Teacher competency benchmarks based on national standards use four aspects .
, namely pedagogic .
eacher's skills in teachin.
, personality and social .
eacher's attitud.
, and professional .
eacher's knowledge in carrying out their role as educator.
( Law of the Republic of Indonesia Number 14 of 2005 concerning Teachers and Lecturers, 2005.
Regulation of the Minister of National Education of the Republic of Indonesia Number 18 of 2007 concerning Certification for Teachers in Position, 2.
The use of these four aspects is relevant to the results of other previous studies by Moynihan et al.
that the formulation of teacher competency measurement can make use of three aspects, namely knowledge, skills, and attitude aspects (Moynihan et al.
, 2.
Besides being relevant based on the aspects measured, the web-based model used is also relevant.
The measurement model chosen was self-evaluation, namely checking the teacherAos self-quality based on the national standards check-list.
This supports the teacherAos professional development program on an ongoing basis independently.
Self-evaluation is considered a powerful method for reflecting on the progress of the teacher's self-quality development (Groiybyck, 2.
addition, the developed instrument can help teachers conduct formative competency measurements every semester.
Formative assessment every semester is expected to be used as a basis for corrective actions to develop self-skills (Chepko & Doan, 2.
Furthermore, the use of the web as a medium aims to increase teacher activity in the use of information and communication technology.
This is relevant to the results of other studies, where the use of information and communication technology was proven to have a positive impact on the pedagogical role of teachers (Andyani et al.
, 2.
CONCLUSION
The instrument for measuring teacher competence supports efforts to achieve quality education and has become a global issue that is directly related to teacher quality.
Teacher professional development (TPD) is one solution to improve teacher quality.
Improving teacher quality by meeting the demands of national standards is an appropriate strategy for developing countries to ensure that national goals are achieved.
This article contributes to efforts to improve teacher quality in the form of an instrument for measuring teacher PE competencies based on valid and reliable national standards.
In addition, research findings indicate that gender, the school Copyright A 2022, author, e-ISSN 2442-8620, p-ISSN 0216-1370 Cakrawala Pendidikan: Jurnal Ilmiah Pendidikan.
Vol.
41 No.
October 2022, pp.
principal's leadership policy and style, and working period are believed to be variables that influence teacher competency.
It is recommended that the implementation of TPD be based on working period, specifically for PE teachers in the working period of 10-20 year who experience static growth in their competency.
This has implications for the Indonesian government and future ACKNOWLEDGMENT The study was funded by the Minister of Education and Culture of the Republic of Indonesia, under the supervision of Lembaga Penelitian dan Pengabdian kepada Masyarakat Universitas Negeri Surabaya.
REFERENCES