Public Health of Indonesia Napirah MR et al.
Public Health of Indonesia.
2016 March.
: 10-19
http://stikbar.
org/ycabpublisher/index.
php/PHI/index ISSN: 2477-1570
Original Research
ANALYSIS OF INA-CBGAoS FARE AND GOVERNOR REGULATION FAREON
SURGERY AT INPATIENT ROOM OF UNDATA REGIONAL PUBLIC HOSPITAL
IN PALU
Muh.
Ryman Napirah1*.
Rasyika Nurul2.
Riru Dwi Anggraeni2 Health Administration and Policy Department.
Public Health Study Program.
Medical and Health Science Faculty.
Tadulako University Accepted: 20 March 2016 *Correspondence:
Muh.
Ryman Napirah E-mail : ryman_smart@yahoo.
ABSTRACT
Aim: In order to determine the fares of surgery, there are two types of fares used by hospitals namely Indonesian Case Based Groups fare (INA-CBG .
and Governor Regulation fare.
This study aimed to identify and analyze both types of fares in orthopedic surgery, general, eyes, midwifery, mouth.
ENT, urology at inpatient room of Undata Regional Public Hospital in Palu during year 2014.
Method: This was a quantitative study with descriptive approach with 46 cases as the number of surgery.
Data were collected through observation and analysis of secondary data were gotten from medical record, pharmaceutical installation of IBS/IDR, inpatient therapy room (Matahari.
Aster, and Teratai pavilion.
and cashier of inpatient room in form of cost details and patient data from January to December 2014.
Data Presentation was formed on tables, where the existing fares are grouped based on the component of each cost then summed and calculated the deviation between the two types of fares.
Results: This study indicated that orthopedic surgery with deviation of Rp 11.
365, general surgery with deviation of Rp 6.
409, eyes surgery with deviation of Rp 45.
741, midwifery surgery with deviation of Rp 6.
765, oral surgery with deviation of Rp 6.
659, and urological surgery with deviation of Rp.
Conclusion: It can be concluded that INA-CBG's fares are higher than Governor Regulation fares except orthopedic surgery, where the Governor Regulation faresare higher than INA-CBGAos fares.
Key Words :INA-CBGAos Fares.
Governor Regulation Fares,Surgery INTRODUCTION Health cost in Indonesia has been being a problem for years.
NHA system adopted by government is not running This may be due to less of funding for health and health service, while preventive effort in definition of early diagnosis to rehabilitation needs large 1 In this case, then scheme of obligatory social insurance is the best solution because of risk of curative service cost can be transferred to some other people by paying the regular premium, therefore, government has made a policy included into laws number 40, 2004 about SJSN.
Regarding to SJSN, government, subsequently, ratified laws number 24 year 2011 and determined a social security agency (BPJS) which was transformed from Askes Inc.
and Jamsostek Inc.
SJSN agency and was officially implemented on January 1st 2014.
2 Service APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 10 A fare in hospital comes from 2 different sources which are out of pocket payment based on governor regulation fare which was determined by both hospital and insurance agency either private or social insurance that is BPJS.
BPJS payment system is based on INA-CBGAos (IndonesiaCase Base GroupAo.
payment in which BPJS determines payment packet of each diagnose aimed as quality and fare Meanwhile, governor regulation fare accounts claim based on the service details given.
2 The implementation of INA-CBGAos system is not effective yet as there is tendency of fare rate of INACBGAos that is bigger than governor regulation fare and is reinforced by a study which shows that there was fare difference between INA-CBGAos fare and governor regulation fare for cesarean.
Based on the study result, mean of difference between those governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares for cesarean at General Hospital Tugurejo Semarang for detriment was 1,273,595 rupiahs and profit was 274,437 Fare comparison of inpatient care service of INA-CBGAos fare was 61% of governor regulation fare which exceeded INA-CBGAos fare packet.
In Palu city, almost all hospitals have incorporated with BPJS, including Regional Public Hospital (RSUD) Undata Palu.
Problem encountered in RSUD Undata Palu was there are 2 basics of fare regulation and INA-CBGAos fare.
Based on the interview result to the hospital parties of RSUD Undata, there is no such study of comparison between governor regulation fare and INA-CBGAos fare in hospital for some diagnoses of disease, hence, there has not been known whether or not the administering health service especially surgery action which requires more 3 RSUD Undata has determined 2 kinds of fare which are BPJS fare based on INA-CBGAos fare and general fare based on governor regulation.
These 2 patterns, subsequently, contributed different impact toward hospital income.
3 Thus, the aim of this study was to understand and to analyze both INA-CBGAos and governor regulation fares toward orthopedic surgery, general surgery, eyes, midwifery.
ENT, and METHODS This was a quantitative study with descriptive approach with 46 cases as the number of surgery.
Data were collected through observation and analysis of secondary data were gotten from medical record, pharmaceutical installation of IBS/IDR, (Matahari.
Aster, and Teratai pavilion.
and cashier of inpatient room in form of cost details and patient data from January to December 2014.
The data were analyzed through descriptive statistic and were described descriptively and displayed into table of Unit Cost and comparison of each surgery treatments as well as described and analyzed factors affecting these two kinds of fares.
Data Presentation was formed on tables, where the existing fares are grouped based on the component of each cost then summed and calculated the deviation between INA-CBGAos fare and governor regulation fare.
RESULTS
The number of surgery treatments gotten during data collecting was 46 cases, comprising orthopedic surgery, general, eye, midwifery, oral.
ENT and urology Most of which was orthopedic surgery 11 cases and the least was 2 cases of urology surgery.
APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 11 A Tabel 1.
Unit Cost of Service toward Orthopedic Surgery Types of Orthopedic Surgery Medical LOS Post Debridemen upper body Repair TendonExtensor Fraktur Femur Close Fr Femur Skin Loss Cruris Close Fr Distal OD Fr Tibia-Tibula Therapy Table 1 depicts description of Unit Cost of orthopedic surgery within the highest surgery was OD fracture TibiaFibula which was 37,979,256 rupiahs and the least was close fracture distal surgery Supporting Medicine Total which was 4,884,128 rupiahs.
Meanwhile, the highest LOS was on skin loss cruris which was 19 treatment days and the least was close fracture distal surgery which was 2 days of service.
Table 2.
Comparison between Governor Regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on Orthopedic Surgery Types of Orthopedic Service Surgery Class Post Debridemen Upper Body Repair Tendon-Extensor Fr Femur i Close Fr Femur Skin Loss Cruris i Close Fr Distal OD Fr Tibia-Tibula Total114.
Table 2 reveals comparative analysis between both governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on orthopedic surgery.
INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation fare within the highest difference was on repair tendon-extensor surgery which was 1,334,950 rupiahs and the least was on upper body which was Governor Regulation Fare INA-CBGAos Fare Differences -1,334.
264,683 rupiahs.
In contrast, the orthopedic surgery where governor regulation fare was higher than INACBGAos fare with the highest difference was on OD Fr Tibia-Fibula which was 11,311,365 rupiahs and the least was on close fracture femur surgery which was 166,441 rupiahs.
Table 3.
Unit Cost of Service on General Surgery Types of General Surgery LOS
App & combustion Struma
Metronontoksik
HIL
App Akut Nursery Cost Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total Medical Cost APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 12 A Herniatomi & Hydrocele Susp Fr Pedis Table 3 depicts types of general surgery of patient with cash payment comprising into 7 types of surgeries.
The surgery with the highest total cost was 4,776,875 rupiahs and the least was HIL surgery which was 2,517,750 rupiahs.
The highest LOS was on acute App surgery, hemiatomi and Hydrocele with 10 days of service and the least was HIL surgery which was 4 days of service.
Table 4.
Comparison between Governor regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on General Surgery Types of Orthopedic Surgery Service Class
App & combustion GR
Struma Metronontoksik
HIL
App Akut Herniatomi Susp Fr Pedis Total Governor Regulation Fare i i i i i Table 4 lists cost difference between governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on general surgeries.
The INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation fare on Struma Metronontoksik.
HIL, acute App and Herniatomi surgeries with difference of each surgery was 1,241,500 rupiahs, 3,404,750 rupiahs, 2,230,625 INA-CBGAos Fare Differences rupiahs and 1,370,881 rupiahs respectively.
Meanwhile, on App & Combustio GR II and Susp Fracture Pedis surgeries, governor regulation fare was higher than INA-CBGAos fare with difference was 263,100 rupiahs and 94,528 rupiahs Table 5.
Unit Cost of Service on Eye Surgeries Types of eye
Surgeries Pterigium OD
OS Cataract Post
Uveistis OS Trauma Couli Lensa & Intra
Okuler
OS Cataract
Senilis OD Trauma Oculi
Laserasi
Medical Cost
LOS
Nursery Cost Table 5 depicts types of eye surgeries from patient with cash payment comprising 6 surgeries.
The surgery type with the highest governor regulation fare was OS cataract Post Uveistis surgery which was 5,727,609 rupiahs and the least was Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total Pterigium OD surgery which was 1,474,500 rupiahs.
The highest LOS was on Lens Procedure Surgery and intra okuler and OD Trauma Oculi Laserasi which was 5 days of service and the least APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 13 A one was Pterigium OD surgery which was 2 days of service.
Table 6.
Comparison between Governor regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on Eye Surgeries Medical treatment Cost Types of eye Surgeries LOS Nursery Cost Pterigium OD OS Cataract Post Uveistis OS Trauma Couli Lensa & Intra Okuler OS Cataract Senilis OD Trauma Oculi Laserasi Total i i Table 6 lists difference between INA-CBGAos and governor regulation fares.
Pterigium OD surgery was the highest fare difference in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation fare which was 10,293,200 rupiahs.
On OS Cataract Post Uveistis.
Lens Procedure & Intra Okuler surgeries.
OS Cataract Senilis dan OD Trauma Oculi Laserasi urgeries Supporting Treatment Cost showed that INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor fare within difference of each surgery was 2,887,491 rupiahs, 4,522,966 rupiahs, 6,069,900 rupiahs and 7,153,772 Meanwhile, on OS Trauma Oculi surgery, governor regulation fare was higher than INA-CBGAos within difference was 113,388 Tabel 7.
Unit Cost of Service on Midwifery Surgery Types of Midwifery Surgeries LOS Ruptur Fimbia Kiri Seksio Cesarean Seksio Cesarean Nursery Cost Medical Cost Table 7 depicts unit cost of nursery on midwifery surgeries over 2 types of surgeries which were cesarean in class i that was 3,397,514 and the lowest fare was Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total on cesarean in class II that was 3,154,535 rupiahs and similar LOS that was 4 days of Table 8.
Comparison between Governor Regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on Midwifery Surgeries Types of Midwifery Surgeries RuptureLeft Fimbia Seksio Cesarean Seksio Cesarean Total Service Class i i Governor Fares Table 8 is an analysis of fare difference between governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on midwifery surgeries and the analysis showed that INA-CBGAos Fares Difference INA-CBGAos fares was higher than governor regulation fares, the highest difference was true on Rupture Left Fimbia surgery which was 3,348,614 rupiahs.
APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 14 A Table 9.
Unit Cost of Service on Mouth surgery Types of Mouth Surgeries LOS Fr Mandibula Fr Dental Alveolar Laceratum vestibulum Saliva Gland Nursery Cost Table 9 shows than on mouth surgeries, there were 4 types of surgeries within the highest unit cost was on Fracture Mandibula surgery which was 7,574,500 rupiahs and the least was on V.
Medical Treatment Cost Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total Laceratum Vestibulum surgery which was 3,421,550 rupiahs as well as the lowest LOS that was 3 days of service and Fracture Dental Alveolar was the highest one which was 7 days of service.
Table 10.
Comparison between Governor Regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on Mouth Surgery Types of Mouth Surgery Fr Mandibula Fr Dental Alveolar Laceratum vestibulum Saliva Glands Total Service Class Governor Regulation Fares i i Table 10 depicts comparison between governor regulation and INACBGAos fares, on Fracture Mandibula there was a difference for 2,899,100 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation fare and so was on Fracture Dental Alveolar surgery and INA-CBGAos Fares Difference saliva gland procedure, 1,656,700 rupiahs and 2,872,150 rupiahs respectively.
However, on V Laceratum Vestibulum surgery, governor regulation fare was higher with fare difference was 1,322,291 Table 11.
Unit Cost of Service on ENT Surgery Types of ENT Surgery LOS Susp Fraktur Polip Nasi SeptumDeviation Chronic Tonsilitis Nursery Cost Medical Treatment Cost Table 11 indicates unit cost of service on ENT surgery and there were 4 surgeries which had the highest surgery fares which was 4,443,500 and the least one was chronic tonsillitis surgery that was Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total 3,506,750 rupiahs.
The highest LOS was on fracture suspect which was 9 days of service and the least one was on septum deviation and tonsillitis surgeries.
Table 12.
Comparison between governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on ENT Surgery Types of ENT Surgery Susp Fraktur Service Class i Governor Regulation Fare INA-CBGAos Fare Difference APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 15 A Polip Nasi Septum Deviation Chronic Tonsilitis Total i i Table 12 indicates difference between INA-CBGAos and governor regulation fares on ENT surgery, on chronic tonsillitis, governor regulation fare was higher than INA-CBGAos within difference of 712,350 rupiahs, in contrast on fracture suspect surgery, polip nasal and septum deviation surgeries.
INA-CBGAos fare was higher within difference of 2,351,950 rupiahs, 3,987,600 rupiahs, and 591,659 rupiahs respectively.
Table 13.
Unit Cost of Service on Urology Surgery Types of Urology Surgeries LOS Nursery Cost Batu Ureter Carcinoma Buli Dinding Post Medical Cost Table 13 shows unit cost on urology surgery within 2 types of surgeries which were Batu ureter and Carcinoma Buli dinding post surgeries and the highest unit Supporting Treatment Cost Medicine Cost Total cost was 9,465,875 rupiahs as well as the highest LOS between two of which, 18 days of service.
Table 14.
Comparison of Governor Regulation and INA-CBGAos Fares on Urology Surgeries Types of Urology Surgeries Batu Ureter Carcinoma Buli Dinding Post Total Service Class i Table 14 depicts comparison between INA-CBGAos and governor regulation fares, on 2 these types of surgeries, batu ureter surgery.
INA-CBGAos fare was higher which was 5,760,688 rupiahs and likewise, on Carcinoma Buli Dinding Post surgery, governor regulation fare was higher with difference was 1,659,175 rupiahs.
DISCUSSION
Among all surgeries in 2014 which was 1,791 cases, general orthopedic surgery, general, midwifery, eye.
ENT and urology surgeries, patients who made cash payment .
ut of pocke.
were 46 patients.
This small number was influenced by implementation of social insurance (BPJS) per January 1st 2014.
Based on the Governor INA-CBGAos Fare Difference interview on officer at RSUD Undata for inpatient care cashier unit, there were many patients registered with cash payment status, however in the several days later, they registered as BPJS patients thus their status turned into insured 4 This case is along with Permenkes Number 2008 about BPJS participation, that is patients who is willing to participate in BPJS insurance is given 3x24 working hours since she/he been treated or before leaving for home.
Should not he/she show his participant identity of JKN, hence he will be determined as general patient.
A hospital should control length of service day as LOS may affect payment system of hospital.
1 Like several APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 16 A .
arcinoma buli wall posterio.
, among all available surgeries, length of service day on orthopedic and urology surgeries was higher than the others with the highest LOS was 19 and 18 days of service This case was not along with the teory of Barber Johnson about efficiency of ALOS which s 3 Ae 12 days and is suggested to be as lower as possible without affects quality of service.
Length of service may imply to other treatments, for instance medicine cost.
2 The longer the length of service (LOS) the higher the cost required to patient.
Nevertheless.
BPJS does not account the LOS.
Unit cost of medicine on several surgeries is high enough, medicine was true as the biggest portion of health payment, approximately 30-40% of health cost used for medicine procurement.
1 On several cases, medicine cost was almost equal or even higher than other medical and supporting treatments.
This might be due to practitionerAos behavior affected by pharmaceutical industry.
5 There should, therefore, some medicine standardization subsuming the medicine based on therapist effect, and subsequently arranging medicine list which is cost-effective, profit-margin pharmaceutical parties.
Service cost comprises inpatient care service and consultation fares.
6 The service cost also might be influenced by doctorAos decision.
This may trigger cost of service on each surgery is different.
Medical consultation is mostly done at orthopedic surgery, however, several surgery details may not be included hence it may affect the cost of health service.
The highest service cost also may be affected by LOS, the longer the LOS, the higher the cost of service nevertheless, it is not assessed in determining INA-CBGAos fares.
Surgeries thoroughly depicted that INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation fare.
Based on the interview on person in charge of JKN RSUD Undata, things influenced the low of governor regulation fare was because of it has been 4 years, the fare is not reviewed, in contrast.
INA-CBGAos fare is reviewed every 2 years (President Regulation number 12 year 2013 chapter 39 line .
with template costing arrangement based on LOS.
BOR and the amount of Service day Length, officers, operational cost excluding wage, staffAos increment, other service cost, medical equipments for the next 5 years, building investment cost for the next 40 years and width it of building.
Those factors have affected INA-CBGAos fare which was higher than governor regulation fare on several types of For instance on eye surgery in which the difference between these 2 types of fare was significantly difference and so were other surgeries in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher.
The high INA-CBGAos fare gives impact on service administered on health offices and indirectly affects their In contrast, if the governor regulation fare is higher than INA-CBGAos, it will make deficit toward hospital with similar surgery case but on BPJS patient.
Reviewing available fare by increasing fare should need analysis from economic The things need to be considered in determining fare is ability to pay and willingness to pay as these two things will affect social demand in utilizing health 5Contingent valuation is the most technique to assess patientsAo preferences through eliciting their WTP.
7 Contingent valuation methods to determine public willingness to pay (WTP) are wellestablished tools to estimate the benefits of safety and environmental policies.
8Ability of society was an important variable to be considered in determining regional fare of APublic Health of Indonesia Ae YCAB Publisher.
Volume 2.
Issue 1.
January-March 2016 | 17 A RSUD Undata since it was a government hospital which oriented on social function.
CONCLUSION
From study result on RSUD Undata, it can be concluded that analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on orthopedic surgeries showed any fare difference for 11,311,365 rupiahs in which governor regulation fare was higher than INA-CBGAos.
Analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on general surgeries showed any fare difference for 6,438,409 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor Analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on eye surgeries showed any fare difference for 45,173,741 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos Analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on midwifery surgeries showed any fare difference for 6,645,765 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor Analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on mouth surgeries showed any fare difference for 6,105,659 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos Analysis result of governor regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on ENT surgeries showed any fare difference for 3,809,959 rupiahs in which INA-CBGAos fare was higher than governor regulation.
Analysis regulation and INA-CBGAos fares on urology surgeries showed any fare difference for 4,101,513 rupiahs in which governor regulation fare was higher than INA-CBGAos.
If INA-CBGAos fare is higher, hence it will be impacting to health service received by health officers, however if governor regulation fare is higher, thus hospital parties will pay a deficit.
It is suggested that for regional Public Hospital Undata Palu, it is suggested to do review of governor regulation fare in order to make it possibly alike with INA-CBGAos fare since it may affect production cost and current fare might be under unit cost, except on orthopedic surgery because in several cases, the fares exceeded INA-CBGAos This review of governor regulation fare must be confirmed on ability to pay and willingness to pay of society.
It is also suggested to the following researcher to do a study about inpatient therapy fares on non surgery cases and reckon unit cost of RSUD Undata as well do a survey about ability to pay and willingness to pay of society, hence it can be a suggestion for health payment in hospital.
REFERENCES